Majdanek became a ghetto after the invasion of Poland in 1939. It then became a POW camp. After the Wannsee Conference, Majdanek became an add-on death camp. That's why the gas chambers were located in the front of the camp.
Unlike Auschwitz, the Nazis did not have time to destroy the gas chambers and crematoria. I actually got to enter them.
The camp was also not built away from prying eyes. It could easily be reached by car, and all sides of the camp were exposed as no trees surrounded it. Even the crematoria and gas chambers were visible from the outside, so claims to "not have known" by the locals are ludicrous and impossible!
Newly arriving Jews were tricked once again into believing that their fate was okay. They had every reason to believe they would work, as people were walking around everywhere. The barracks were falsely labeled as Bath and Disinfection Centers, so as new visitors they wouldn't suspect they were going to DIE!
Majdanek was captured whole in July 1944. Unlike what happened in Auschwitz, the Nazis had no time to evacuate the camp or to burn it and destroy the evidence. The story of Majdanek was featured on the front page of the New York Times, then as now, the most prestigious of American newspapers.
H.W. Lawrence, a correspondent for the New York Times, wrote: “I have just seen the most terrible place on earth.” These revelations were not given much credence. The very existence of something as awful as a death camp seemed impossible. Even graphic films of the camp shown in Britain and the United States were dismissed as Soviet propaganda.
Because it was captured whole, Majdanek is more primitive, more actual, and more real.
Look how deceitful the Nazis were. They labeled the barrack Bath and Disinfection. They told the victims that "Now a better life for you will begin. You just need to be ready to work hard. Your hair will be cut because of lice so you need to get disinfected." They were SHAMED to get NAKED in front of everyone! Jewish people were taught to be very modest, even in front of their families. When you are naked, there is no resistance. Notice how the construction of the barracks changed.....It went from wooden planks to bricks. The brick building was the gas chamber. When I walked through the crematoria, it still smelled of burning charcoal after 70 YEARS!
Click on pictures to read in detail the process of death and deception.
Deceptive showers. The prisoners were told to get naked and to REMEMBER where they put their belongings....Really? In a room with 3,000 people? But they did their best....not knowing that they would never come back to this room to retrieve their possessions. They were gassed in the next room.
Carbon monoxide was supplied through metal pipes connected with two steel cylinders.
Zyklon B was also used here. The remnants from the poisonous Zyklon B stained the walls blue.
This is the peep hole the Nazis looked through to make sure all were dead.
To make pavements, the Jews would roll the heavy barrels...Guess what they made the pavements from....Headstones from Jewish cemeteries.
This was the place of roll call. Remember, before Majdanek was a death camp, it was a POW camp. So Polish "prisoners" asked to make their place nicer. Germans didn't suspect a thing and were trying to be "nicer" because they needed them to work. What the Polish "prisoners" did was erect a statue. The base of the column is made from ashes. The eagle became a symbol of freedom, the turtle became a message to work SLOW, and the lizard cautioned them to be smart.
There were ravens and crows everywhere.....I think they smelled the death.
Largest massacre of Jews in one day....30.000 people were buried in these pits.
Dome memorial.....translated to "Let our Fate be a Warning to You."
Underneath the dome are preserved ashes from the bodies. Close up, you could even see bone fragments. I tried to capture the perspective of how much ash there was.....Look at the person in the background and how small he looks compared to the mountain of ash!
OMG! When we went to the US Holocaust Memorial Museum in DC, we were nauseated by the smell of shoes in a small area. Look at all the shoes here. The following poem says it all:
Shoes
Visitors would walk through a barracks of shoes, the shoes of 500,000 Jews from the various ghettos and camps, who entered but did not leave.
Moshe Shulstein, the great Yiddish poet wrote of these shoes:
I saw a mountain
Higher than Mt. Blanc
And more Holy that the Mountain of Sinai
On this world this mountain stood.
such a mountain I saw—Jewish shoes in Majdanek….
Hear! hear the march.
Hear the shuffle of shoes left behind—that which remained.
From small, from large, from each and every one.
Make ways for the rows—for the pairs—
For the generations—for the years.
The shoe army—it moves and moves.
We are the shoes, we are the last witnesses.
We are shoes from grandchildren and grandfathers,
From Prague, Paris and Amsterdam,
And because we are only made of stuff and leather
And not of blood and flesh, each one of us avoided the hellfire.
We shoes—that used to go strolling in the market
Or with the bride and groom to the chuppah
We shoes from simple Jews, from butchers and carpenters,
From crocheted booties of babies just beginning to walk and go On happy occasions, weddings and even until the time
Of giving birth, to a dance, to exciting places of life…
Or quietly—to a funeral.
Unceasingly we go. We tramp.
The hangman never had a chance to snatch us into his
Sack of loot—now we go to him.
Let everyone hear the steps which flow as tears.
The steps that measure out the judgment.
What else can I say? You decribe those horrific events that you saw in your journey to the death camps in Germant Poland and the Czheck. You are a true ambassador
ReplyDeletefor the millions and millions of the Jewish people who did not make and couldn't tell the horror they suffered. REMEMBER AND DON'T FORGET
I find it surprising that the camp was in plain sight, and that the locals didn’t do anything. Knowing that the locals lied about “not [knowing]” astonishes me because not only did they lie, but they didn’t help. Why didn’t they help? Were they sacred? Or did they hate Jews?
ReplyDeleteReading about the arrival of the camp scares me. Knowing that in such little time one’s whole life can be destroyed and ruined. In such little time, all faith and hope diminishes because one knows they are trapped and doomed for trouble. I can’t even imagine the thoughts running through all of the young Jewish children!
Learning about the “disinfection process” frightens me because of all the hardships one went through in such little time. The carbonic acid wash mainly frightens me because one can get carbonic acid poisoning from touching it. Imagine how sick one can get from taking a bath in it!
A little smile crept on my face when I read about the statue the Polish Prisoners made. They made a symbol of freedom and hope in the middle of a NAZI CAMP! How ironic! I can’t believe it is still standing!
The poem helps me put into mind how many Jewish people were killed! Hearing about the shoes and the possible backgrounds add an emotional touch to the shoes. It makes the story more realistic because I can relate. I can see the shoes in my head.
I can’t believe the camp was out in the open and still no one spoke up. That makes me so mad. What confused me is the smell in the air. Couldn’t the new Jews arriving smell the burning bodies and know what was in their future? Even if the Nazis told them otherwise. Seeing the blue stained walls was scary. I remember watching the movie, “The Boy in the Striped Pajamas” and seeing the blue gas go off at the very end. I’m sicken to even see how stained the walls were with blue; it means they much of used the gas chambers a lot. The thought of that makes me so sad to all the people who died in the chambers. I thought it was interesting how they put the ashes of the first people who died in the camp in the inside of the base. The big dome of ashes is also very sad. It looks so wide and tall and I can’t imagine all pain each on of those people suffered through this camp.
ReplyDeleteThis just seems so unreal. I don't see how this could ever happen, but i know it did. Im glad that they were unable to destroy this hell. It gives people proof that this WAS real. I don't understand how anyone could think this massacre was fake. why would someone make this up? Wow. The gas chambers. That's insane that you were able to enter and to know that millions died inside. Seeing these pictures really allowed me to picture the people squished inside that tiny room. One thing that killed me was the peep hole; i felt like the Nazis were some how watching me. It disgusts me that they will look and see if they're dead yet or still suffering. The worst part about this whole thing is that it was in plain sight. No trees. No walls. Anyone could see that something awful was happening; there is no denying it.
ReplyDeleteReading this and looking at the pictures really made me think about what life in the concentration camps would have been like. It’s easy to accept the reality of the Holocaust as a fact, but it’s much more difficult to think about what it would actually be like to be there during that time. The pictures of the outside of the buildings make the camp look so innocent, so I can understand why most of the Jews didn’t suspect that they were going to be killed. The picture of the showerheads also showed how cruel the Nazis were; their cruelty wasn’t simply tricking the Jews, but it was also the fact that someone had to build the showerheads while most likely knowing that they were going to deceive hundreds of thousands of people heading to their deaths. The carbon monoxide tanks, the blue-stained walls, and the story about the boiling showers and carbolic acid baths also showed the cruelty of the Nazis. I can’t even begin to imagine someone today or someone I know killing people in such inhumane ways; it doesn’t even seem human or possible.
ReplyDeleteI also couldn't believe that the camp was in plain sight, and no one did anything about it. I would like to believe that if I were to live near a place where thousands of people were being killed every day, I would try to stop it. It's disheartening to hear that there were many people who knew about the camps and acted like they were normal and later pretended they didn't know about them.
However, I was glad when I read that the Nazis didn’t have time to destroy the gas chambers and the crematoria. There is now genuine, full proof of the horrors of the concentration camps. If these were destroyed, people in the future probably wouldn’t believe that the Holocaust happened, so it’s important to make sure they stay intact and are never forgotten.
This is upsetting. You would think that if this camp was out in the open, someone would try to speak out, but no. it makes me sad to think that the Jews though they were being “disinfected” but really they were going to die. How awful of the Nazis to just mislead them like that. I can’t even begin to imagine what you were feeling as you entered those gas chambers. I’m glad that they weren’t able to destroy them. This is proof that the Holocaust really did happen, and it shouldn’t be taken lightly. The amount of ash that is piled underneath the dome is unbelievable. It’s crazy to think that many people died and more! No one deserves to go through what the Jews went through in these camps.
ReplyDeleteSurprisingly, I am kind of glad that the Nazis didn't get a chance to destroy the remains of this camp. I know that probably sounds weird, but the fact that everything is still intact makes the feeling you get when you look at these pictures hit harder. This is proof that the Holocaust really did happen, and it makes me sick. Seeing images of worn down and almost gone buildings makes it seem like it happened so long ago and that it's just a story from the past, but the places only look like that because the Nazis burned them. Looking at these images of the walls that are still blue and of the statue remind us that this is something that REAL humans did. Not just any real humans - our grandparents and great-grandparents. At this camp, they killed thousands of people everyday, AND you could still smell the charcoal! It's really scary to think about. Another thing that shocked me (though it shouldn't considering how inhuman the Nazis were) was the fact that they would make the Jews strip, give up their possessions, and take a shower that would end up killing them. I just don't understand how you could treat people so horribly and sleep at night.
ReplyDeleteI think seeing pictures of a concentration camp that wasn't destroyed makes it seem a lot more real. Like Anna said, seeing pictures of torn down buildings makes it seem so far away and a lot less scary than it actually was. The pile of ashes was really shocking to me... it's hard to imagine that all those people had a life, friends, and family, and that was all taken away from them. I like the statue the Polish prisoners put up in the camp. It's ironic that they had a symbol of hope in such a cruel, seemingly hopeless place.
ReplyDeleteThis camp definitely stood out the most to me; so many things about it shocked me. There is no excuse for villages not being able to see what was going on while this camp was up and running because it says that the camp was clearly visible. It makes me sick to realize that people can live by a death camp and not say anything while they watch innocent people get killed every day. Seeing the pictures of the blue stains on the wall from the Zyklon B gas made it all seem real to me. I cannot get over how blue one spot on the wall looked; it was ridiculous. The statue was also a very powerful part for me. I think it is amazing how the prisoners secretly built a huge statue in remembrance of what happened there. It is funny how the Nazis had no idea; it makes them look stupid. I cannot believe how big the ashes were under the dome. I almost started crying when I read that 30,000 people were killed in one day and buried in the pits. I have never seen 30,000 anything, and I cannot imagine seeing that many dead bodies. Those people must have either been extremely brainwasher or sick because that seems impossible to me.
ReplyDeleteI knew death camps existed, but I never really thought about them in-depth before. There were real places where people were just sent to die, and nothing else. That's it. The deceit of the Nazis is also extremely disappointing. I feel so terrible for the people who expected a chance but only got death. The number 30,000 is also shocking. I cannot even fathom that number; 30,000 people died in one day. That's the same as 10 Myers Parks full of students. The only reason I'm even able to come to terms with that number is the dome and the shoes. Seeing the shoes that were removed from innocent feet and the ashes and bone fragments of the victims are the only images that put it in perspective. I can actually SEE how many people died, which is absolutely horrifying. The Zyklon B stains make me feel a slight pang of guilt; the colors and patterns left by these stains, although unsettling are beautiful. It sickens me that I can even consider something so vile to be in any way, shape, or form beautiful. It hurts my heart that cemeteries were defiled. I have a deep love and respect for cemeteries; the fact that headstones from cemeteries were used to make pavement just tears me apart. Was it not enough to murder the living? Did they HAVE to kill any chance of memories of those who were already gone?
ReplyDeleteI think that the camp being in plain sight and people still not saying anything about it shows how people will let things happen as long as they aren't affected. The camp was surrounded by towns, so many people must have seen the prisoners and the shipments of "cargo" that went into the camp. The towns had bystanders, and the more that we read about the camps the more I realize that many people just let the holocaust happen. Now going to the topic of gas chambers. I was really stunned when i saw the blue walls. to become stained from the gas it had to be really working at max capacity. it's crazy that 70 years later the crematoriums smell like charcoal, i would've thought that the smell would have gone away by now. i think the smell of the crematorium staying in the air stands as a reminder that the horrors of the holocaust won't be forgotten, neither will the victims.
ReplyDeleteI
ReplyDeleteThat was powerful. Mrs. Stone how did it feel to walk into those gas chambers? I personally wouldn’t be able to do that because it will give me nightmares. This is actually very sad. The people knew about the camp because it was hidden, but they still did nothing about it. I think as today this place is probably the most horrific place on the planet. It is ironic how they told the victims that,” a new better life for them will begin,” to the Nazis a better life for the Jews was death. It still smells like burning charcoal? Wow after all them years? That’s just so sad. I didn’t know that there was still a full death camp. I thought all of them were destroyed before the war ended. This death camp shows how humans can turn from normal to monster like creatures.
ReplyDeleteI am still in awe that people still use the excuse that they didn't see the camps, even when they were in plain sight. It's like the Milgrim experiment we saw, where the "teachers" laughed to hide their guilt. I am relieved that the Nazis didn't have time to destroy this camp. You get to see everything from the floor up and gives you a sense of how the Jews felt. The euphemisms disgusted me. The Jews already had to die, and now, they died with false hope. What the polish did was smart. The use of symbolism in the statue probably helped many in the camp try to stay strong. The hill of ashes is depressing too. The saddest thing was that the pavements were made out of the Jewish headstones. Did Jews have to go in the cemetery and take them out too? Seeing more of these camps makes me realize that Hitler had so much hate for people who didn't even cause pain to him directly. How can you kill so many without feeling not one bit of shame? It seems inhumane to have so much hate.
ReplyDeleteI thought the transformation of Majdanek from a ghetto, to a POW camp, and finally, to a death camp shows the transgression of Nazi ideals from isolation, to punishment, and finally, to extermination. Also I admired the sculpture or monument with the symbolic animals, yet I must say I am curious as to how and why the Nazis allowed the prisoners to build such a thing that would produce hope? Anyway, I could only imagine that the gas chambers must have been an eerie sight to behold. To know that you were walking through the location of more than tens of thousands of Jewish deaths is both heartbreaking and unwelcoming. Finally, the enormous pile of ashes. Wow. After seeing this in person one be must be in sorrowful astonishment at the scope of death, which lays there in a pile. A pile, one might consider that rather undignified.
ReplyDeleteI can't even being to talk about the camps location and how exposed it was to the surrounding towns because Ill get too angry. But it's not just the townsfolks's excuse of having "no idea what was happening", it's the Nazi's complete understanding of their to be bystanders. The had so much faith in their assessment of the cowardly nature of the Polish and German people, that they had no fear of resistance. So much confidence that they saw little risk of the complete exposure of the camp to the surrounding towns. out of all the school years of seeing disturbing pictures from the holicaust, strangely, one of the most shocking things I've ever seen was the dome and it's mountain of ash. I think incorporating this type of memorial to the museum really conveyed how REAL it all is. That mound of ash is thousands of wives, children, brothers, aunts, mothers, fathers, etc. who's lives had been stolen from them by the Nazis and that camp. The tangible representation of the human beings who were maliciously murdered there, erases any desensitized thought on the Holocaust the viewer may have had. Even then, it's still unfathomable. I Also loved this poem, and the pictures barracks of the abandoned shoes really resonates with the reader.
ReplyDeleteI'm going to go right ahead and start with what affected me the most, and the thing that affected me the most was both the giant pile of ash and the mounds where the Jews' bodies were buried. I was so shocked by the amount of ash mostly because when we had my brother cremated, it wasn't that large of an amount, so for the hill of ash to be that big, there must have been so many bodies. The mounds also made an impression on me for that very reason. I've said this every time I've commented on your blog but this really helps put the entire Holocaust into a more realistic perspective and I really appreciate that you took the time to do this for your students. I admired the statue though, and what it stands for. It gives off a sense of pride for the people who died there.
ReplyDeleteTo be treacherously told that you are going to hold on to the most important gift given to you and have that gift taken from you is unmoral at a completely different level. The Jews were petrified. As they walk among the deathly grounds, they cower in what is next to come. Only a sadistic monster can have a heart blackened enough to deceive these people with their lives. Frankly, they might not have hearts at all. The fact that this place was completely omniscient of the local Germans, makes me cringe at the society we most likely live in. To know that people are being tortured, killed ,and completely deprived of their souls a short distance away from you, should be more than enough to impede you to take initiative. As a bystander, you are just as bad as those Nazis. By being a bystander you remiss your duties as a humane person. That very child behind that door that grasps his last breath could have been yours or even you.
ReplyDeleteIt makes me sickly when I think about how many Jewish prisoners had been killed in this one camp. How could 30,000 Jews be killed in ONE DAY and the surrounding citizens say that they "didn't know what was going on"? To think that the amount of people buried in those pits is the same amount of people that were killed in one day astounds me at the sheer number of prisoners that had died at that camp. When I saw the picture of the dome, I thought that it was maybe a burial site for a few of the Jewish prisoners that represented everyone that died at that camp. Although, when I saw the large mound of ash, I felt ill. That was before I saw it in comparison to the man in the background. So many deaths, and to think that this was just one of the many death camps doing these terrible things.
ReplyDeleteThe locals near Majdanek "didn't know" of the horrors occurring in the camp, even though it was clearly visible and accessible, "they didn't know". It's actions like these where the German people have to suffer, and share the guilt for what the Nazis did, the German populace allowed these atrocities to be committed and still tried to justify their actions for not taking any. The mountain of ash was disturbing, just thinking about how many people the Nazis killed on regular basis is jaw dropping. One of the survivors' stories quoted how he believed that they a glimmer of hope when he saw the people, oh how very wrong he was, the Nazis were the master of deceit. To think this was only one of many operating death camps just demonstrates the vast number of horrors committed by the Nazi Scum.
ReplyDeleteGermans, for the most part, are not like that today. They are very remorseful and take responsibliity.
DeleteNazis are a different story...most think what they did was fine. but there's a distinction between nazis and germans.
DeleteIt was weird reading this and knowing that this particular DEATH camp was clearly visible and open for the public to see. I don’t know how the citizens didn’t hear the screams and cries for help of the Jews who were being killed every day. It’s complete bs when the citizens said that they didn’t know about the gas chambers and crematoriums but it could be true that they didn’t really know what was going on in there. I highly doubt that the Nazis were telling the public about them killing about 20,000 Jews a day on average (I’m guessing. I don’t really know). I would like to believe that the German citizens wouldn’t allow this and try and revolt but after what I’ve learned in this unit, I truly do not have much confidence in that belief. Also, I found it a little rude for a U.S correspondent for the New York Times to not have known what was going on in the camps. I mean, the American government should have at least told him what he was going into before so he wouldn’t be scarred for the rest of his life. Finally, I was really confused on the three entries from the Jews you had taken a picture of. I was a confused to when they wrote it because in all of them, they were each about to die.
ReplyDeleteGarrett Hensley
the sonderkommandos heard this and documented it.
Deletethe sonderkommandos heard this and documented it.
Deletethe sonderkommandos heard this and documented it.
DeleteI swear that every time I read another one of your posts I cringe more and more. Just the awful facts you described really have made me look at life in a different way. The fact that the people around the camp did notice something is unacceptable. Could they not see the piles of dead bodies and the awful smell. You could reach it by car for God's sake... did the people not say anything because they didn't notice it or were they afraid they might end up there for saying something? Also the fact that you got to walk in the gas chamber where millions of Jews died is surreal to me. Just the pictures of that camp gave me goosebumps. I think you're right about the crows...maybe they did feel the death. in addition, The fact that they stacked that many bodies in one pile is gut wrenching. Hopefully the next post wont be as bad.
ReplyDeleteI can’t imagine what it must have felt like when you entered the gas chambers and crematoria. I also wonder what was going through everyone’s mind when they saw this camp and said nothing of it. Out of everyone, a small group of witnesses never tried to make a difference? Wow. I can’t believe the Nazis went as far to label the barracks as Bath and Disinfection Centers and even tell the Jews “Now a better life for you will begin. You just need to be ready to work hard.” Not only were the Nazis mass murders, they took the time and effort for tricks such as that. However, I like the symbolism of the statue, but unfortunately, it’s made from ashes. I also find it hard to believe that 30,000 people were massacred in a single day. Those people didn’t even get their own graves either; they were all buried in one massive one. When I see the massive pile of ashes, I remember you telling our class how it’s a Jewish custom to be buried rather than cremated. Not only were the Jews subjected to and killed by the horrors of the Holocaust, but they didn’t even get to be properly buried. The whole thing is painful to learn about.
ReplyDeleteLike I mentioned in the other blog, the Nazis were so deceitful. The Jews thought that they were going to be taken care of, but little did they know that they would die. Reading about the showers reminded me of when my older sister first told me about them when I was little. I remember her telling me the same thing that I read in this article, and I didn’t really believe it. A couple years later, I started learning about it in school and thought, “Omg, she was right.” When I looked at the picture of the man next to the mountain of ashes I was aghast and SHOCKED! That’s A LOT of ashes! I wonder how they got the ashes. I didn’t think that the Nazis would have kept them.
ReplyDeleteIt's hard to believe how oblivious locals were to the camp. The fact this death camp wasn't destroyed is odd. I can't imagine how surreal it was to walk through the same places your ancestors walked through. It's really upsetting to always be reminded the different ways Nazis tricked the Jews into obeying their orders. I thought the symbol was interesting since it portrayed a message to newcomers. It's ironic how you saw crows and ravens during your visit to this death camp. The pile of ash and shoes emphasize the cruel and mass killing the Nazis performed. This is history that should never be forgotten.
ReplyDeleteIt sickens me to think of how the Nazis tricked the Jews into thinking they were going to take "showers," but instead, they trapped them like animals and gave the Jews a "shower" of death. The idea that the Nazis could kill 30,000 Jews in one day is also very disturbing. I am starting to agree with your view that the Nazis were inhuman monsters. No person would send wave after wave of innocent people to their deaths every single day. I wonder if the Nazis viewed it as an accomplishment to kill so many people in one day. They were probably proud of themselves. What an "achievement."
ReplyDeleteyes, some viewed it as an accomplishement and bragged.
Deleteyes, some viewed it as an accomplishement and bragged.
DeleteAfter reading each blog, the horrors of the Holocaust seem to get worse and worse. By just looking at these pictures, you would think that this death camp was just an old ranch or barn. It's crazy but smart how decieving the Nazis were. It just shows the extent at which the Nazis were willing to go to to murder the Jews. I also cannot believe how the locals were blind to this camp. It was out in the open, and the locals definitely knew about the trainloads of people coming in but not leaving. It just goes to show the consequences of the bystander effect.
ReplyDeleteI can't believe that this death camp was just out in the open. With no trees or anything to try to hide it... And that the people never tried to report it or anything. They had to have known what was going on. With seeing many people get dropped off, the sounds of them crying and screaming for help, and even the smell of charcol and fumes. It is so disturbing to read that even the Jews did not know what they were going into. With the Nazis telling them they were all going to take a "shower" but in reality being put into a gas chamber with them all about soon die. The picture of the dome with all the ashes is crazy. It is sicking to see how big of a pile of all those ashes added up to be. I still can't even believe how all these men could ever do any of the things I keep on learning about.
ReplyDeleteThis is probably the worst camp so far... Not only is it awful how they tricked the Jews into believing that everything was okay, but also how they took the dead tombstone away so they could make pavement. This is scary to think that the locals did nothing to help the Jews. I mean, it is in clear sight and you could probably smell something odd. It must have been really scary walking and seeing all the ashes of the people who were killed... I could not imagine walking up and seeing that. Also, the death chamber looked extremely frightening with all the blue stains...
ReplyDeleteIt's very hard to read through and put yourself in this situation. What happened in this camps is unreal; it's very hard to believe something so horrible could actually happen. A place where literally nothing but death happens is basically hell.
ReplyDeleteI was surprised to read “It could easily be reached by car, and all sides of the camp were exposed as no trees surrounded it. Even the crematoria and gas chambers were visible from the outside’, but I wasn’t as surprised to learn that the German citizens did nothing about the atrocities that were occurring in the camp, and claimed that they “did not now”. It kind of reminds me of the videos we were watching in class and “First they came for they Jews”, because in both there was a lesson that could be learned… Most individuals get involved if it personally affects them, although the Germans were oblivious of their surroundings, not knowing that if they would have acted or expressed their opinions on the inhumane treatment toward the Jews, they could have saved countless of innocent lives.
ReplyDelete-Chris.M
HOW WERE LOCALS OKAY WITH THIS! If they clearly saw the camp and saw how many people came out of the trains and seeing the trains in general and the smell! Did they all just turn a blind eye? I cannot think of a reason on why not to speak out against this, but then again back then it wasn't the most common thing to speak out.. But still. How do you not just feel the pain and wrongness in your gut! This camp is just too cruel and evil. I do bet the crows and ravens smelled the death! They are the symbol for evil and death! I cannot believe that it still smells like charcoal after all this time!!
ReplyDeleteI can’t believe people used the excuse they still didn’t know about the camp when it was in visible sight. Of course they were able to see the smoke coming from the gas chambers, and they were able to smell the burning bodies from the crematorias. It’s such a pathetic excuse that they gave that they were just “unaware” of the situation. They hold blame in turning their heads the other way while people were being violently treated.How could actual evidence of the camps be so easily brushed to the side by important countries? I couldn’t imagine how chilling it would be to look into the gas chambers where millions of defenseless people were violently murdered. So many innocent lives were taken right where you’re standing. It is hard to imagine the treachery and trickery that the Nazis used to corral the Jews into the bath and disinfection area. I continue to be astonished by all the horrible things the Nazis did.
ReplyDeleteThis is yet again another terrible camp where even more atrocities occurred. I think that is good that the Nazis could not destroyed this camp because now there is a completely intact camp that not only shows but proves that the Holocaust did happen so that I cannot be denied, even though some still do. I found that the camps were just dismissed because they were just assumed to be soviet propaganda. Governments need to take matters like that more seriously and not just write it off as something else, and they had more evidence that it was happening too. The fact that the Jewish people were forced to strip down shows the Nazis even deeper contempt for the Jews by making them do things that go against Jewish beliefs among many other things. The story of the political prisoner, Jerzy Kwiatkowski once again made it more real for me, and the gigantic pile of ash as well as the hundreds of shoes made it more real as well
ReplyDeleteWilliam Jolly
Although some “outsiders” might have helped in other forms, the part I still don’t quite get is how easily these people could announce that they “had no idea” what was going on. Given that the camp is in plain-sight, easy to get to by car, and not covered with trees, it is hard for me to believe that so many people were “blind” about this entire process. Were they too scared to step up? Were the “bystander” actions out of pure fear? Would people turn a “blind eye” if this happened again today? The personal excerpts about the “bath and disinfecting” processes were really outstanding in means of description. I was shocked at how quickly these Nazis tricked the Jews and how quickly the process was completed. These Jews were dehumanized in every way possible. They were stripped naked of clothing and hair, which made them even more vulnerable and unable to resist. I couldn’t imagine how it could have felt to have been treated so poorly that soon to my death. Lastly, the fact that you could still smell the burning charcoal after 70 YEARS amazes me. If the smell still exists today, I can’s imagine how many lives were taken.
ReplyDeleteThat must have been hard for you to actually walk into the gas chambers and crematoria. Did you feel anything when you walked in through these? It annoys me that the locals didn’t see what was happening. I know they are lying because they had a choice, and they chose to be silent and ignore what was happening. I think it’s amazing how this was one of the death camps that didn't get destroyed so now people can really go back and take in what it was like for the Jews as remembrance. I think it was good that when this camp was captured it was finally exposed for everyone to truly see. The injustices the Germans had committed for so long had finally been revealed to the whole world to see. I’m not surprised crows were everywhere since they’re a sign that bad things are happening.
ReplyDeleteThis has to be the most powerful of the blog entries I have read so far. Seeing the complete death camp makes it feel that much more revolting. Looking at these pictures made me feel like there was something evil that happened there. Even if I had not known the origin of these pictures, they still would have seemed to contain some evil. After looking at these pictures, it really sets in that hundreds of thousands of people died in those gas chambers, which is nauseating to me. Also, the fact that the death camp was just blatantly out in the open for everyone to see is shocking. Even more shocking is the fact that no one did anything to stop what was going on there, though I'm sure it was rather obvious.
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteThese pictures sent shivers down my spine. Seeing the huge pits where 30,000 people were killed in a single day is horrifying. I still can’t understand how the SS officers could kill these tens of thousands of people without once questioning the morality of their actions or attempting to understand that the Jews are more than just the number they were assigned. Furthermore, the picture of the gas chamber, by far, resonated with me the most. I can’t imagine the bravery it took for you, as a Jewish woman, to step into the same place that so many people of the same religion were brutally slaughtered. It’s much larger than I would’ve expected but just as disturbing as I imagined. The fact that so many people were packed into the chamber that they still remained standing, even after death, is utterly shocking; imagine opening the doors to the chamber and seeing all of the bodies completely erect and knowing that they’re all dead. I don’t know how those who had to evacuate the chambers could’ve handled seeing that terrifying image day in and day out.
Again, I am disappointed and disheartened by the bystanders. However, I am not surprised. The Nazis were barbaric and had the power to publicize death in front of a whole town and get away with it. The fact that they had a small risk of getting "in trouble," yet they did it anyway just shows the Nazis' audacity. The pictures were disturbing; however, I am glad that majdanek was not burned because it brings more awareness. In fact, I am glad that I was able to see the pictures because it gives me a better understanding. The most powerful was probably that of the ashes. I can't believe that there were still pieces of bones in the ashes; it must have been so hard for you to stand amongst an enormous pile of what was once people. Furthermore, it must have been insane to walk through a room that watched hundreds die. You must have been on an emotional rollercoaster.
ReplyDeleteI can't believe that the camp was in plain view and no one spoke up for what was right. This recurring problem makes me so mad. It seems unreal. I am glad that the Nazis didn’t have enough time to destroy this place. That way it will always survive as a constant reminder of what happened. It gives the world proof that this was real and it did happen. The fact that you were able the enter the gas chambers is insane. Didn’t it give you chills just know that millions died right where you standing? Seeing those pictures allowed me to see those one hundred people squished into that one tiny room to die. Another thing that got me was the peephole. That’s just sickly twisted. The Nazis would look through the peephole to make sure every Jew was dead. Just the fact that you could still smell the charcoal from so many years past just made my stomach turn. I couldn’t have stood in that room with that smell.
ReplyDeleteThis information given about the Majdanek death camp/ghetto creates such a depressing mood into the reader. I can't think about anything else but just how disgusting these insidious minds of "leaders" were. Reading more, I just can't help but think of the bystander as being just as guilty. They acted as if they were out of the loop on information about the camps when all of the evidence was right in front of them. These "ordinary" citizens didn't manage to do a single thing to prevent another man's death. I just can't imagine the pain and suffering these unfortunate souls had to experience. How cruel these people could be? How inhumane their actions were! I can't imagine the emotions you had while witnessing all of this. These "leaders" the German citizens followed and supported throughout life prove to be nothing but barbaric animals with deceitful minds. Unbelievable.
ReplyDeleteI hate the fact that the Nazis were so deceitful. The Nazis were monsters. The Jews were violated in so m any ways that I had not even realized. I did not even now that the Nazis made the Jews strip their clothing in front of everyone. I can only imagine how scared and degraded everyone felt. I am actually glad that the Nazis did not have time to flee from the camp and destroy everything. By not destroying the camp, future generations will have the ability to gain more understanding of the conditions and what the Jews went through. When you showed the picture of the gas chamber, I could literally see/feel death when I was looking at it. When you look at the gas chamber, i could just imagine all of the people that were tricked into going in. It is really really sad.
ReplyDeleteTo be honest, I’m really not impressed anymore about the fact that some of the camps, this one included, were in plain sight. But still, I find it so disgusting that all of the locals didn’t do anything about the whole situation. What really makes angry is how the Nazis still tried to trick the Jews by saying that their fate was secure. Also, the fact that they labeled the barracks as “Bath and Disinfection Centers” is so pointless. Why did they even have the need to lie to them if they were going to kill them a second later? Again, pointless. I’ve met some people in my life who claim that the Holocaust never happened, so I’m actually “happy” to read that Majdanek is a clear evidence of this horrible genocide. I say it every time, but the huge amount of shoes really makes me sad. Lastly, I really love how the Polish “prisoners” erected a statue to show their strong form of resistance.
ReplyDeletethis comment was from Ginny Ammannato
DeleteHumiliating the Jews like that is so disrespectful and inhumane. Labeling the bath and disinfection as if it were normal is so digesting and petrifying, however, it made me feel relieved to know that the Nazis didn't have time to destroy the evidence of the camp. Now people can view the camps and see what the Jews actually went through. People hear about what the Jews went through, but to physically walk through the site makes them realize what horror they experienced ; that's what they need to see, not just hear about it. Your blogs and teaching have really opened my eyes to see another perspective of the holocaust, but walking through the camps would be a true impact on my life. I already know the museums will feed me more information about the holocaust, and i'm excited to go.
ReplyDeleteI find it disturbing how they would make a former POW camp/death camp in plain sight. It's just disturbing how the civilians kne what was going on, but they didn't do anything to stop it. Of course even if they tried to stop it, the Nazis would probably try to lie about what it was. I also find the fact that they mislabeled everything disturbing. The innocent people thought they were simply going to be disinfected, take a shower, and work. I just couldn't imagine the feeling of walking into that small chamber to your death. The fact that the chemicals of the Zyklon B would stain the wall blue is creepy. It just makes the chamber look less human. Also, the fact that you were still able to smell the coal made me feel weird. They killed so many people, that the area was stained with these things!
ReplyDeleteIt nauseates me to learn how close people were to this concentration camp! The fact that crematoriums and gas chambers were visible to the public yet the people living right behind it remained silent horrifies me! How could people bear to watch that happen?! How they didn’t speak out terrifies me! The pictures of the gas chambers were so scary! It is crazy that the poisonous gas was virulent enough to stain concrete!! I can’t imagine the horror of walking into a gas chamber with no space, no windows, and no light. I was unaware that the barracks were connected to the gas chambers. I thought they were separate! The Nazis were horrible and disgusting to trick the Jews into thinking that they would be taking showers but instead they would be gassing them!
ReplyDelete- Madison Bain
This whole thing just hits home for me. I have never actually seen a true concentration camp until just now. I have always imagined what one would be like. I have seen plenty of movies about the Holocaust to know generally how a camp may look, but in reality they are nothing compared to what I have just seen. Just seeing the damp, bule-stained, cement walls of the chambers where chilling enough. Almost if out of a horror movie. Seeing the peep whole was even creepier. one thing that stood out to me was the fact that the peep hole was the only thing with light. almost as if to symbolize that that hole was the only thing connecting them to the outside world. A hole that monsters and butchers would later use to make sure all the life was gone from that same room.
ReplyDeletecliff Ricciardi
ReplyDeleteEverything that the Nazis did was so horrible that it always seems like it has to be made up. I mean with this camp was IN PLAIN SIGHT! They weren't even trying to hide the camp! The Nazis weren't human; they lied as they promised the Jewish people a new, better life. They were promised that they wouldn't be harmed. Never in my life would I think a pile of shoes would have such an emotional effect on me. There are just so many of them.. each belonging to a person who was brutally murdered.. I can only imagine the feelings you had when you were there.. Another thing that really affected me were the mass graves.. If you were not told what they truly were, you'd believe that it was just a picture of rolling hills. It scares me when I think of just how awful and inhuman these monsters were..
ReplyDeleteI found it both depressing and fascinating that Majdanek was preserved perfectly. It felt like looking at a millennia-old fossil and yet there are Holocaust survivors still alive today. The bit about modesty answered questions I’d had for a long time. Modesty is a theme (or rather a motif) in the Bible/Torah, and forcing the Jews to get naked seemed like an additional slap in the face to the Jews; you confirmed this. The murder of 30,000 Jews in a single day is unfathomable. That’s three times the size of the Knight’s Stadium!!! I was also disappointed in America’s indifference once they learned of the disgusting events taking place in Majdanek. I don’t believe that bystanders can always be considered guilty, but America is certainly guilty in this instance. And the base of the statue being made from ashes… the Nazis were clearly proud of all the horrible things they did.
ReplyDeleteThese pictures really hit home with me. Whenever I see pictures in black and white ,I imagine the people in black and white too. Now that I see a death camp in color, I can see something this awful actaully happening. The Nazis were very talented in deceiving the Jews. It's one thing to label the gas chambers as bathrooms, but they put fake shower heads in the gas chambers! This could have been a good thing though. Knowing your about to die must be the worst feeling ever. So not knowing that you are about to die is probably better. I would have so many things to get off my chest like Karl, the former SS soldier.
ReplyDelete30,000 people were murdered in one day....wow. That's insane. Nazis having so much murder of their hands justs makes them evil. I could not handle this many deaths. Some Nazi must have had to stand up and say something because no normal person should be able to handle this.
Shoes. Shoes never change.
ReplyDeleteThe poem about shoes is very interesting. I think that the author was trying to point out that there were still traces of the victims left. The mound of shoes is holy because it marks the Jewish people's struggle; they had suffered the greatest sacrifice for their beliefs! So, to an extent, their shoes gain some of their holiness. I also think that the picture with the single raven in it is a very mediocre example of "There were ravens and crows everywhere..." I also remember the book The Devil's Arithmetic had a scene where the prisoners were split in half, and one half went to the showers; the other were never seen again. The tombstone pavement is a perfect example of how the Nazis detested the Jews; they were literally walking all over the name of the dead. I hope that as the poor souls realized their fate that they were able to make peace with themselves. I hope that the Nazis were goggling at them. I hope they saw the human in the eyes of the Jews as they were swallowed up by the blue gas.
30,000 people's lives taken in one day is absolutely mind boggling and what's even worse is that the Nazis probably saw that as an accomplishment, considering their goals was to completely eradicate all Jews. It makes me glad that the Nazis didn't have time to destroy the camp. The world needed to see what it was like and how bad these Nazis actually were. They were disgusting. I found the poem quite interesting also. I liked how the author wrote the poem from the perspective of the shoes. This shows that people from all walks of life, literally, were killed. People of different ages, countries, races, and religions were all sent here to be killed.
ReplyDeleteIt's very strange and disheartening to see a camp not destroyed like that. And getting to see the inside of the gas chamber is astounding. I can't imagine people being packed into that small room and then killed. I sort of wish the camp had been destroyed, but at the same time, I'm glad to be more educated on the events that took place. It is easier to picture the life they were forced into. The stories people told were so tragic. I don't even think I could live with that.
ReplyDeleteIt is heartbreaking to know that everyone knew about the camp, yet nothing was done to stop all the killings. Did some people actually agree with the Nazis? Were they to scared to do anything? I cannot say what I would have done if I were in that situation, but I hope that I would have said or done something. I also hate how the Nazis tricked the Jews into thinking that they would be alright. While this is awful, that was probably the only way the Nazis could get the Jews to cooperate with them. Still, the fact that they even had death camps is sickening. Why were the Americans and British so very ignorant of their surroundings? It's terrible that people would try to deny something as huge and atrocious as the Holocaust.
ReplyDelete-Nicholas Glenn
This is the kind of thing that keeps me up at night. They didn't tear it down so it's all there. The blue walls are sickening because they tell you just how much the gas was used. They tricked Jews to their own deaths, clever, but evil. There is a saying that there is a special place in hell for all evil people. I wouldn't be surprised if the Devil himself spat the leaders of this murder horror right out of hell in to oblivion. That ash pile was huge! After 70+ years, it's still there? Jesus! To stand there knowing that those are the thousands of people killed. Lying there. Ash.
ReplyDeleteI find it interesting (and scary, for that matter) that the Nazis all seemed to take the "issue" of the Jews so personally. Granted, there were some Nazis who acted on that in a good way, hence the fact that we're watching Schindler's List, but to even bother with making pavement out of the headstones of Jews... That just seems so completely unnecessary, even in terms of the vile killing machine that was the Nazi regime. Getting rid of the headstones is one thing, but making the Jews use them as building blocks just seems so repulsive that it implicates something of the mental state of the Nazis. Why was it that they all developed this burning hatred inside of them? Was Hitler truly that effective? Is society really just that easy to meld?
ReplyDeleteThe shoes!! The shoes!! Those are what are left of the millions of Jews that were considered as animals. Who could do such things as to create a mountain of shoes which he/she took from the innocent lives of children and old men and women. The ravens and crows definitely represent something. The world will always scorn the times in which people were considered as animals and in which Superman was born. The world will always be impacted by the events of the Holocaust. Imagine!! The birds sense the death. Hell yes, they do! Why? Why? Why? Why did this happen? Why was the Final Solution so important. Why did it give normal doctors, engineers, architects, and civilized human beings a pleasure to kill. Not only to kill but also to torture. Why did the Nazis not feel a single thing or remorse for what they constantly did? Can humanity really be stretched to the length of which we don't ha any feelings anymore? Those are the questions that plague me, and all of you, and I don't really know the answers for. I can only get rid of indifference every single time it comes to me.
ReplyDeleteMrs. Stone, I can't imagine how you must have felt walking through these gas chambers. Even walking through the camp must have been a very heartbreaking and saddening experience. The fact that you saw the blue stains and the carbon monoxide is simply too real for me to even imagine. The photo of the ashes really put this whole ordeal into perspective for me. From just that camp there was that much ash? I have said it over and over, but again, I am so appalled and disgusted by this information.
ReplyDeleteI like that the Nazis didn't have time to destroy anything; having the gas chambers as well as most of the camp helps prove that the holocaust did in fact happen and was not faked. I wonder how it must have felt for you to be in the same room that hundreds of people have died in. The pile of ashes also shows and the pit of 30,000 bodies helps put the number of people murdered at this death camp into perspective.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteWhen I read about the shoes and the ashes I was even more appalled. To hear about all the people who died in the death camps is one thing, but to actually see their ashes in a huge mountain, and for that mountain make that man so small brings the death of the Jews on a whole new level. The shoes make me bring the human back into the nameless people who were dehumanized every single day until they were killed. For me to see their shoes piled onto each other gives them the identity as actual people not victims of horrific torture. The statue of the eagle and the other animals gave me a sense of pride. For the Jews to be able to get something to make them proud, and to give them something to keep them going forward is inspiring.
ReplyDeleteI thought that the camps weren’t supposed to be easily accessible. They might not have cared with this one. Even if the people that saw these atrocities were scared or frightened, they really could’ve done something if they cared. I do put most of the blame on Hitler and the Nazis, but a percentage of the killings could have been prevented or avoided if there weren’t so many bystanders. Here they go again with using euphemisms and telling lies! I just can’t stand it. At all. The fact that the barracks were labeled “bath” and “disinfection” is terrible. They might as well say “dehumanizing process, right this way!” It makes me so angry and upset to read and discuss this topic. It is sad that they used an odorless gas in the chambers just so they would still have no clue what was going on. I’m done. I can’t.
ReplyDeleteTo be honest, looking at this as a passerby, I wouldn't want to get involved in what was going on because I don't know anything about it and it wouldn't have been my mess to clean up. I hate admitting to it, but it's true. Also, every time I read one of those little passages that were narrated by a Jew, I was scared that they were going to the gas chamber. Speaking of the gas chamber, the walls of those gas chambers are disgusting. I honestly kept trying to look really closely at my computer to see if there were any scratch marks on the walls that were visible in the angle I was in (at least). It's truly remarkable, though, that those new arrivals still had hope when they saw the other people running around working. Although there still was a chance for the ones there when Majdanek was taken over by the Americans. It's just insane how much false hope these Nazis gave these people. It's almost to the point where even I can't understand it (not that I could in the first place).
ReplyDeleteI got goosebumps all over my body when I learned what the cement was made out of. When I went to my DC trip in 8th grade and visited the Holocaust Museum and I the smell completely overwhelmed me; I can't even image what the room of a "mountain of shoes" would smell like.I can't even fathom how many people were turned to ash and are resting in the dome. There is apart in my mind saying this isn't real and that there is no way 30,000 people can die in one day at one place by one group of soldiers. It just goes to show how insane the camps were and insane the soldiers were. I thought about how one person who is cremated can fit in one small urn, but to have a GIGANTIC mountain of ashes.
ReplyDeletet absolutely befuddled me to think that the things that destroyed so many lives are still currently standing today, and you would think the Nazis would be smart enough to get rid of them. I think it's ridiculous that people claimed not to have known that there was a camp there. Are you kidding me?? It's literally out in the open. The nerve of some people shocks me. Tricking someone into their death is a new kind of low.
ReplyDeleteIt makes me sick to my stomach that this was basically open for the public to watch, yet not a single person stepped up to fight for the Jews. The 30,000 people that were killed in just one day boggles my mind. This means that 1,250 people were killed every hour. That's crazy and so very sad! I remember walking through the room with shoes in the Holocaust Museum in D.C. I couldn't help but gag and run out of the room, and to think that there are mountains of shoes makes me sick.
ReplyDeleteWhy would people near there think they could say "we didn't know." How could they all be so terrible. Why did the Nazis even trick the Jewish people. Why did they think they could get away with it.
ReplyDeleteIt annoyed me how this camp wasn't hidden but none of the citizens did anything. I feel like they were lying when they said they "hadn't known". I am glad though that the Nazis were taken by surprise and didn't have time to tear down any of the buildings or run away. Now, we have a place to teach kids about what happened. It is so disrespectful to the Jews that passed away to use their headstones, but obviously the Nazis didn't care and did anything they wanted to them. I love how the Jews made that statue though. How they used all the symbols like the eagle, turtle, and lizard. Also, I love how they were able to secretly put in ashes from the crematorium. I understand why they used those symbols because they needed to make smart decisions while being the camps to stay alive (lizard), they needed to work slow so they wouldn't be killed after finishing their job (turtle), and they needed to remember that freedom is coming (eagle). I wonder how many Jews were killed and cremated to make that huge pile of ash. I don't even want to think about it. I especially don't want to think about how many kids ashes are in that pile either. It is just very heartbreaking.
ReplyDeleteThe disrespect is unreal. I can't believe they used Jewish headstones for pavement. What in the hell. These creatures have no concept of respect. Reading that made me furious. The blue Zyklon B that has stayed in its place for 70 years gave me chills. In what way is it right to murder innocence and 30,000 in one day. The ratio of the man to the pile of ashes and bones is astonishing. So many people who didn't get to live the lives they deserved. I think the memorial that the prisoners secretly built is gorgeous. I love that they put ashes in the bottom. That memorial gives those lost a resting place. I still can't believe people tried to say they couldn't see the camp. That is ridiculous. The was more than just the sight of it too; there was the smell of death that has lingered there for 70 YEARS.
ReplyDeleteThe thing that shocks me the most is how open the camp is to everyone. I can't imagine driving around my own town and seeing a camp where thousands are being murdered. I would have to say something! I don't understand how the citizens just stood around; they were cowards. I also remember reading in another blog how the Nazis wanted the deaths to be as humane as possible. I think the Nazis did many things to torture the Jews, not make their deaths humane. Why would they shave their heads and tell them to remember where their belongings were? What came out of this deception? It was just cruel and disrespectful.
ReplyDeleteI am utterly shocked by the Nazis' level of sheer disrespect. They paved the roads to the concentration camp out of Jewish headstones? I cannot comprehend what could possibly lead a Nazi to believe that what they are doing is okay. What justification could a person possibly find for this? I get chills every time I read one of your blog entries. I cannot imagine what it must have felt like to see this in person. I felt chills when I read that you could still see bone fragments in the ashes. How could anyone deny the Holocaust after seeing this?
ReplyDeleteIt's interesting to me how the camp is so close to everything and the public. In the background of some of the pictures you can see other buildings and houses. They're so close that its like a backyard. The amount of ashes is staggering, I don't really understand how they'd get them if the bodies are buried or ashes blown in the wind, but whatever. I like how the eagle is a symbol of freedom there as well as here in America. I didn't know lizards were symbols for intelligence though.
ReplyDeleteIt is unreal how much the Nazis dehumanized Jewish people. The fact that the roads were paved with Jewish headstones is sickening. This really shows how much hatred was aimed at Jewish people by the Nazis. The Nazi's use of deception is also sickening. It's disgusted that they made it seem like the camp would be a nice place to live if the prisoners worked hard enough and that they made the gas chambers look like showers. Lastly, I cannot believe how public the camp was. This just goes to show how silence was a powerful weapon in the Holocaust. Those who lived near the camp chose to be silent and ended up appeasing thousands of people's deaths.
ReplyDeleteThe excuses of not knowing about the camps doesn't fly with me anymore. After reading your your blogs and learning about the Holocaust in your class, I find it so mind boggling that they actually thought that saying they didn't know would work. How could one possible be so oblivious to something that horrible when it happens so close by?! Anyone waking by could've seen because there were so many people dying and because it was out in the open! Also, I like how the Jews made a state with different animals to symbolize freedom, message others to work slowly, and to caution each other to be smart, but it's sad that the bass was made out of the ashes from the crematorium.
ReplyDelete- Alexis Reid
The Nazis are the and will always be some of the most cruel people in this world. The road where made from grave stones!!!! The fact that they put told the Jews to remember where they put there clothes is terrible. They were trying to not cause panic, how about not kill millions of people. The fake shower heads is disturbing. Who came up with that sick idea. Like I knew the Nazis where sick people but i had no clue of this extent.-William Smith
ReplyDeleteI was a little surprised that the locals would lie about such a big camp. I mean sure there is fear of being blamed for not helping, but still. They are, again, the most intelligent people in the world. They should know at least that 'not noticing' is a bit far fetched for a lie. My heart felt for the families that had to strip and remember where their things are. I mean i would understand, I am even embarrassed about going to the pool in a two piece because it is too exposing. To think they had to go naked into the gas chambers. I would never understand that feeling. The memorial Dome was what got me to realize that the Nazis really murdered all of those Jews in the gas chamber. I mean all of that ash piled up. That must have been a lot of families who thought they would be safe. They even made Jews clean up or take the bodies of the Jewish people. That honestly made me sick, what if they had to put a family member or friend into the crematorium. I really cannot believe that so many innocent people had to suffer during this time.
ReplyDeleteA lot of people talked about how the mislabeling was wrong and inhumane, but I feel that was one of the most humane things they did. I would rather be lead to a shower instead of them straight saying I was going to be killed. It wasn’t like they would be able to rally up and save themselves if they knew what was going to happen. The ashes of the Jews and their shoes is unbelievable. Out of all the things I’ve seen through these blogs, those two pictures give me the most realistic slap in the face to how massive the Holocaust was.
ReplyDeleteTo think that the camp was not hidden and everything was open for the public to see makes me lose a little faith in humanity. How can you be a witness to as many deaths as the local townspeople were and then lie about it? it is absolutely disgusting to think about. Not only did they lie about it they lived right next to it and never did anything to try and stop the horrendous deaths taking place every day. How could someone live like that? I do find to to be interesting that you were able to see the camp completely undisturbed. As someone who only sees pictures of what happened, I feel that I'm still missing specific details only a visitor to the camps would be able to gather, I find it very impressive that you were able to go into the camp and gather what information you did and then come back and teach it, I personally do not think I would want to think about it if I every visited the camps, however maybe I would. I find it to be inhumane to search the dead bodies of the Holocaust victims for anything valuable and then keep it as your own, that is disrespectful, however the entire Holocaust was a disrespectful act which should have been prevented by common sense. - Liz Montgomery
ReplyDeleteI don't understand the people who would claim that they couldn't see the camp when it was really exposed to the world. I can't believe that all those people would see it but never say anything about it. They were bystanders. How could they just let all those deaths happen and then lie about it? They weren't doing any good for themselves or anybody. It is so humiliating and gross that the Nazis made the Jews strip naked and then march to their death. With promises of false hope, they were horrifically murdered. It makes me sick to think that the smell of the burning coal still lingers more than 70 years later. It makes me sad to think of all the innocent Jews as they were gassed and killed. That seems like the very worst way to die. They were deceived and filled with false hope of survival. I couldn't believe my eyes when I read that the Germans forced the Jews into a tub of carbolic acid; that is completely inhumane and torturous. I like the statue that the Polish prisoners created because it symbolizes how that they should never give up hope completely. It is interesting and crazy how they put the ashes of the prisoners inside of the statue. I can't believe that they kept the giant pile of ash under the dome and was able to preserve it for so long. The big stash of shoes makes me sad because I think of all the owners that they used to have but never again will be worn. The poem about the shoes is very deep and it makes me think that we should appreciate the little things in life. That dome will forever be a memorial for those lost at these death camps and is a something that will never let us forget about these horrible acts that were put upon millions of innocent Jews.
ReplyDeleteA question immediately forms in my mind as I read the third paragraph: How could people let this happen to numerous amounts of innocent people? The Nazis committed what could be called and should be called the worst atrocity in human history. The fact that a group of people could strip people of their family and then their clothes and then march them to death without thinking twice is a burden that the bystanders to this operation should feel forever. This burden is reminded to the bystanders by the lingering smell of burnt coal, the same coal used to slaughter the Jews. It became inhumane once I read that the Jewish people were forced into inhumane torture including being gassed in the thousands after being successfully tricked into stripping naked and giving up all of their personal belongings, which they would never see again. It honestly sickens me to a point where I see any counter-measures should be taken to assure that this will never happen again and that the millions killed by the ruthless Nazi regime shan't have died in vein or without remembrance.
ReplyDeleteI am surprised about how open the camp was. I’m sure that the citizens of the town knew what was going on but just didn’t do anything about it. It is so awful and disturbing how the Jews had no clue that they were going to die. The saddest part is that they were so hopeful that they would be alive and working. One person even thought other people were already there working. I am fascinated that you got to go into the gas chambers. I can’t even imagine how insane that would be, especially with the smell still in there after so many years. Seeing the pictures of the pits where the dead Jewish people were buried breaks my heart. Those hills are very large, people deserve way better than that. The pile of ashes blows my mind too. I am just surprised that it is still there to this day. Every pile is so large, it is so sad, like the pile of shoes. I can't even image how large the pile is. My question is how did people see the pile of shoes? Did they have them sitting out? If so, why didn’t they just burn the shoes? I am in shock with everything I read and saw, it amazes me how now days you can still go into the camps and chambers.
ReplyDeleteHaving the gas chambers at the front of the camp I'm sure is so the "victims" can get off the train and be killed very quickly. It is sick that the Nazis do not even give them time to say bye to their families if the gas chambers are at the very front. Euphemisms sicken me now. Especially in the context of the Holocaust. They are so horrible and tricky and just make you feel another way about something. The Nazis used them to trick the German citizens to believe that what they are doing is good and used them on the "victims" of the Holocaust to make them believe that they will be treated nicely and will not be killed immediately. But that is wrong, what the Nazis were doing was completely wrong and horrifying and the "victims" that were tricked were being sent tot their death. They were not treated nicely and were not treated with respect. They were just sent to their death. They would die that very day or week. The Nazis are literally planning someones own death. They are not God, they can not do that. I do not believe that these "victims" fate was to die in the Holocaust.
ReplyDeleteAnother camp being placed in plain sight makes me wonder how many bystanders were there during this time? The bystanders are as bad as the perpetrators but the amount of the bystanders is far many than the perpetrators. In terms of deceiving, this camp is one of the worst. They put together all of the other camp's deceiving methods and they add it along with their showers and people fake working in fields. The showers were the cruel part because not only were they humiliated, but they were stripped naked both psychologically and physically. They were all shaven with the same unsanitary razors and sent to the showers. They were in a mixture of freezing cold water and boiling water until the Nazis had enough. Shortly after their shower, they were placed into the gas chambers. The order of the way that things happened just makes me feel as if these people were completely shocked, hurt, and confused when they would finally realize that they were to be killed. The pile of ashes must have been something to see because we all know that the whole pile doesn't contain the ashes of everyone who was placed in Majdenak, but only a fraction of it.
ReplyDeleteSo many lives taken here. Once being a POW camp and then a death camp. I don't know how you did all these camps. That gigantic pile of ash is sad that they are all mixed, but represent a small portion of the innocents killed there. I don't know how it could be possible to kill 30,000 people in one day, it's just so much that I can't believe it. SO many innocent lives taken without consideration of what they were doing. The bystanders who claimed that they saw and/or knew nothing is just stupid they knew what was going on. They could smell it for god-sake. I think they should pay just as much for what they did in just watching and letting all these innocents fie.
ReplyDeleteXan Brien
ReplyDeleteI didn't know that there still was a death camp still in tact. It must have been really sad to walk through the gas chambers and see the Zylon B still on the walls and still smell the burnt charcoal 75 years later. What really freaks me out about this camp is the fact the 30,000 Jews were kill on one day alone. The big statue of he eagle is pretty ironic. The sign said that the eagle represents freedom. The Nazis believe that freedom for the Jews is death. And that is just terrible. I hate the Nazis.
It makes me so frustrated that this death camp was in plain sight and yet it was just ignored by so many. Those are the people who could have helped change what occurred at Majdanek. Those are the people that could have prevented 30,000 people from being murdered there in one day. I don’t think I will ever understand how more people didn’t recognize the smell of burning bodies. If you were still able to smell it after 70 years, how did the people who lived in that area ignore it? How did they not notice the huge puffs of black smoke from the cremotorias and revolting smell of chemicals from the gas chambers? I find it disgusting that the Nazis knowingly lead Jewish people, who were deceived by the Nazis, to their horrifying, painful deaths. Even when all hope seemed lost the Jewish people that inhabited the camp asked for a statue to make the camp nicer, this statue was the only glimmer of hope once Jewish people realized their fate. It represented to keep “working” though they knew where they would end up. I remember visiting the Holocaust Museum a few years ago and seeing and smelling the shoes that were there. Not only did they smell disgusting, but they also represented how the Jewish people weren’t allowed to have anything when they died. They were stripped of their clothes, hair, prized possessions, and humanity only to slowly be killed by poisonous gases that left remnants on the gas chambers that we can see today. I just can’t believe everything that happened to these innocent people and I find it heartbreaking that they were killed without a second glance and that the Nazis so easily and effectively deceived thousands of Jewish people to their deaths, while people that lived outside of the death camps ignored what was going on.
ReplyDeleteReading this I actually had to step away from my computer two times and distract myself just because of all the detail it went into. It astounds me how the camp was in plain sight and practically on display for everyone who passed by to see, but no one ever did anything. And the fast that the Nazis deceived them from the very beginning, telling them it wasn't a death camp. It would've been nicer to at least tell them what was going to happen to them, in my opinion. This whole thing was nauseating to read and the whole time I was waiting for something to change or something good to happen but it didn't. This death camp almost seems like it would be the worst because people knew it was there the whole time. They knew what was happening inside those walls, but let it be. No one protested or tried to stop it even in the slightest which is what angers me the most about this whole situation.
ReplyDeleteIt’s crazy that you got to enter the gas chambers. That would be so frightening, I really don’t know if I would be able to ever stand in there. So many people, innocent people lost their lives their I just don’t think I’d ever be able to stand in there. The fact that the camp was so accessible and visible is insane because I’m sure tons of bystanders in the surrounding area claimed they were unaware of what was going on. That is obviously a lie because the inside of the camp could be seen from every direction. Once again I do not understand why the Nazis felt it necessary to trick the Jews into thinking they would be okay. They hated the Jews so why was it such a big deal that they believe they were going to be okay? I just don’t get it. I’m glad in a way that they were unable to destroy this camp because it allows the rest of the world to see exactly what they were turning a blind eye to. I feel like it also allows the rest of the world to really understand how bad what was going on was. It’s absolutely awful what the Nazis did to Jews. They stripped them of their homes and possessions and then embarrassed them and took away their dignity too. They did all this just to murder them. That’s crazy to me, absolutely crazy. The photos of the gas chambers are down right creepy. They’re scary to look at and they are really creepy. I can’t imagine going in their, I would be absolutely terrified. The fact that they used headstones from Jewish cemeteries to make pavements is disgusting. That is someone’s gravestone, who in their right mind would ever take that and then destroy it and use it to make a pavement. That’s disgusting and the Nazis are horrible people for that. 30,000 people in one day is absolutely insane. The mountain of ash is frightening to look at. It makes me so sad because I can’t even begin to think about how many people would have to die to make that much ash. Everything about the Holocaust makes me so incredibly sad, it was an awful event of history and it should always be remembered.
ReplyDeleteI cannot even comprehend the thought of 30,000 people being murdered in one day! It shocks me to think about the people inside those chambers waiting for their certain death, praying and hoping for a way out. There was no end to the 'prisoners' pain, only death it seemed. The smell of the gas chambers would be enough to make me want to leave and never turn back. The amount of shoes that all had a story makes me sad to think about. The amount of ashes under the dome is sickening to think about. To see all of those bone fragments and chunks laying there. It seems that once the officers stripped the prisoners of their clothing, they stripped them of their rights, humanity, and dignity. The statue is a great feature of their protest as it housed the ashes of those that had died. The locals that did nothing are to blame for part of this. They are bystanders, they did not even stop for one second to help.
ReplyDelete-Brady
The fact that death camps were in plain sight is really disturbing, it sheds light on how many people were aware that the mass murders were occuring, and on how normalized murder was. These camps would obviously smell, and there would be dead bodies everywhere, so for Germans to say that they were unaware of the circumstances, and try to place blame on the Nazis is unbelievable. These deaths camps were real, not a thing of the imagination, or something that could be shrugged off, over 30,000 were killed every day. How can Nazis even gather that these people deserved to die, they did not even know there Jewish citizens names, let alone what there life had consisted of. The people in these camps were stripped of their belongings, and treated so horribly but yet Naizs still allowed them to shower which i don’t understand. Why would Nazis let them shower, and the only reason i can think of was so that they wouldn’t have to deal with the stench of the men, women, and children, but the mass of dead bodies probably covered the camps.
ReplyDeleteI cannot imagine going for a drive and seeing a Nazi death camp out the window of my car. The fact that this place was in plain sight and still no one tried to stop it is unbelievable. It is a good thing that the Nazis did not have time to destroy the evidence of what went on in this camp because there is no question as to what kinds of bad things the Nazis did. All the evidence is right there. The gas chambers, the torture chambers, the horrible living conditions… Now anyone can visit this death camp and see just how ruthless the Nazis were. It doesn’t bring back the lives that were lost but at least people know the horrors of what happened at Majdenak. It is so difficult to look at the pictures of the gas chambers because I am thinking about the thousands of men, women, and children who thought they were just going to shower but actually ended up dying. It is heartbreaking. I cannot imagine how it would feel to stand in that room.
ReplyDeleteI still cannot understand how Germans could sit by and stay quiet when they know thousands of Jews are being killed in their town. I mean they didn’t even try to hide the gas chambers!!! Seeing the gas chambers in these pictures really makes you think about what it would have been like. Tight and cramped, exposed and vulnerable. The Nazis stripped the Jews of everything before they murdered them too. They took their belongings, hair and clothes. This kills me seeing how vulnerable they must have felt before they died. Seeing your picture of the mountain of ashes truly puts it into perspective of how many people were killed and how it was not that long ago at all. I also think the ravens and crows are there for a reason, and that reason being to symbolize all of the death their. Its horrifying seeing this massacre of people happen at a place that was not disguised and easily visible while no one tried to stop it.
ReplyDeleteAt first I didn’t know what a POW camp was. I looked it up and it is a Prison-Of-War camp that was a site for the containment of enemy combatants captured by a belligerent power in time of war.I would have loved to explore the gas chamber but at the same time feel terrible for all that happened in the gas chamber. I feel like the Jews couldn’t have not been tricked. They only had hope for someone to rescue them and hope that the Nazis would spare them for working. I was glad they weren’t able to burn down the camp before they left because it gives those who are visiting a true vision and aspect of what the camp looked like. It’s terrible that the Nazis made these modest Jews undress in front of everyone!It’s incredibly demeaning for a modest person to have to do that. I can’t imagine having to do that.
ReplyDeleteIt kind of came no surprise to me that they had no trees around the camp to block the people who were driving by from looking in. However, in another blog post you described how everyone could see into that one camp that was shaped like a triangle just like in this blog post you described how everyone can see into Majdanek. I found it quite awful when the Nazis had labeled the barracks different names so no one knew what exactly was happening, not even the jews. However, I did find it interesting that you went into see the barracks and were able to see first hand what the inside looked like. I also thought it was cool that when you were talking about how before it was a death camp it was a POW camp and how they had to believe in those statues to keep themselves from moving forward and to not stop. -Riley Dilsworth
ReplyDeleteI think it's fascinating to read about concentration camps and ghettos because they I have never seen one in person nor are they popular where I live now. I still don’t understand how you could be in a death camp and have no clue that you are about to die. This camp sounds much different than most that we’ve learned about. I am surprised that it was not hidden at all especially if it was a death camp. Why would they make it visible? It’s awful to hear that the Jews were tricked into believing that their fate was okay when they entered the gas chambers. How could people falsely labeled the barracks as Bath and Disinfection Centers, so as new visitors they wouldn't suspect they were going to die. I just don’t understand. It was very interesting to look at all the pictures, since I have never seen a death camp before.
ReplyDelete-Ashley LeBlanc
i cant imagine what it would be like to be a prisoner at that camp, being tricked into thinking you will be working and getting a good shower before you do so until carbon monoxide and ziklon b are pumped in killing you and everyone around you slowly. I cant imagine going for a run and passing billowing plums of smoke and a fleshy smell in the air. Im glad they didn't have time to dismantle the place and that all the evidence is right there.
ReplyDeleteWhat is a POW camp? And it was converted into a death camp so something like Treblinka? Everytime a gas chamber is mentioned I can’t help but to feel some type of way. Last year we watched The Boy in Striped Pajamas and that movie broke my heart. At the same time though I had to think this is what he gets for accompanying himself in something like this. Another thing that bothers me is how bad the Jews were lied to. From when they were captured to the arrival at the camp they were always told, “it’s gonna be okay,” when that was truly not the case. I’m glad camps like this still stand today as an example of many things. One of the biggest being don’t let hatred control you and your morals. This consequently has led to one of the worst incidences this word has ever seen.
ReplyDeleteIts awful to even think about what the Nazis did here. It’s even worse to think that the Nazis actions were displayed in broad daylight and no one took action to stop them. This truly shows how inhumane the Nazis were. I have no idea what state of mind you have to be in to even think about doing something like this to thousands of innocent human beings. The fact that 30,000 Jews were killed in one day is atrocious. That is close to killing someone every second. It sickens me to think of how the Nazis deceived the Jews. And the way the Nazis shamed and humiliated the Jews for no reason should show everyone how barbaric the Nazis really were. I can’t imagine what it was like for the Jews to be humiliated in front of their peers. I wonder how badly the survivors were scarred mentally. I can’ imagine a place so full of hate and awfulness.
ReplyDeleteThis camp looks like a horror movie was just shot, but it wasn’t no movie. They actually killed thousands of Jews by gassing them in that room that reeks of hell and anger. You were super brave to go in the camp. It was probably harder for you because you are Jewish. I could never see the house of terror used against my people. The mountain of ashes is the remains of all the Jewish people that passed away in that camp. Like you said, that man in the distance looks so tiny compared to all the ashes of the Jewish people. This camp was the most emotional one to me and hopefully i could go visit that place to pay my respect to all the lives lost.
ReplyDelete-Wilson Hawes
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteIt is just terrible what the Nazis did, but I am glad they were not able to destroy this malevolent, belligerent camp they created. It stands as a reminder that it happened and we shall not let it be forgotten. I also thought it was insane how much ash there was under that dome. I just can not believe that humans would do that to other humans. I also thought it was sick how they stripped all of the Jews of their clothes and told them they were going to take a “shower.” The Nazis making pavement out of Jewish headstones was really messed up. I just don’t understand how you could do something like this. I don't understand how in good conscious someone could watch the death camp (because the people outside the camp definitely knew what was going on) and how someone could be apart of the killing machine. We can never let this happen again.
ReplyDeleteIt is crazy to think about what the Nazis did here. The Nazis actions were displayed and no one acted on it. I find it so crazy that no one stepped up to them. I feel that in this time period it would have been different. I feel that countries (including the US) would step up. I also can’t believe how the prisoners came to be. Coming in, they thought they would be provided with a good and healthy life. Little did they know, they would soon be tortured and most likely killed. This is just not right. No person should be able to do all of this stuff and walk away from it unphased. I am still disgusted by everything. The fact that the Nazis killed the Jews just because of their religion is terrible and I am mad that no one stopped it. This is crazy and should never happen again.
ReplyDeleteIts unnerving to know that the camp was in plain sight and turned away and acted as if they saw nothing. It is unbelievable that you could just ignore what was happening. To call polish and Jewish people “prisoners” of war is so wrong in so many ways because they were not soldiers. It was a living hell even to imagine the beyond crowded so called barracks just to be guarded to your death like an animal. To see the the burning pits and the mass graves puts everything in perspective to how many lives were lost in just this one camp. The pile of ashes must have been overwhelming, beyond overwhelming overpowering is a better word for it. For a place to burn 30,000 people in one day then it was a meticulously thought out process. I do not know how anyone could be able to sit down and come to decisions on the best way to burn people and get rid of their bodies.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteAfter reading this specific blog, the experience you had at Majdanek was very eye opening to me personally. I believe that it was almost a positive considering the fact that the Nazis never got the chance to destroy the camp in the sense that the remains have been turned into a learning experience to our history. It is interesting considering how eye opening it was to me even though I’ve never stepped foot on that camp. I could only imagine the learning experience you had after your trip throughout Majdanek. Although it is a very sensitive topic, I believe that the remains of ashes, shoes, and death in general are very important, allowing visitors to get a better visual of the actual living conditions in the camp. This is also very helpful because those who may not be able to make the trip to that camp, can get a physical image to imagine the ways of life in Majdanek.
Moose M. III
With this specific death camp, I am just amazed that the citizens of the surrounding towns completely ignored the fact that people were dying all around them. They were being complete bystanders and also playing a part in letting the Nazis get away with all these murders. I also feel so sad for the prisoners that had to come to this camp. Because it looked like a normal one from the outside they weren't automatically thinking about death they thought that they would have a bit longer to live. I would already feel so betrayed by having my surrounding community shun me but even more by being mislead to my death.
ReplyDeleteI am utterly shocked that they told them that everything would be okay when they entered into the camp. It frustrates me even more that New York Times wrote about the camp giving evidence that the annihilation of the Jews was a real thing that could potentially have been prevented. The account from the Slovakian Jews who gave a description of what it was like to go through the camp gives me goosebumps. I hate this for everyone who had to deal with the pain and suffering. The shoes make me feel awful for those who walked in them. The outcome of anyone who was wearing them was death and to see all of the shoes piled up is awful. Seeing the barracks and the “disinfectant” sign makes me hate the Nazis even more. It is sad to know that people still today are Nazis and frown upon the Jews who have gone through Hell.
ReplyDeleteReading about the death camp Majdanek, I felt a sense of satisfaction knowing they were not able to destroy any of the evidence of the camp and all the atrocities committed there. The fact that everyone around the world was able to see just what the Nazis did to the innocent people and still they did not believe something like this could happen is astonishing. The people thought that the graphic videos showing the events of the Holocaust being committed could not be real due to just how graphic they were, and attributed it to Soviet propaganda. I felt bad for the Jews as the people of the United States and the United Kingdom watched the horrific real crimes being committed to them by the Nazis and they thought that something so bad could not be real. I really did not like looking at the massive burials and mass graves. It was really unsettling to look at, and I thought about all the unnamed people who were put there.
ReplyDeleteThis blog has brought a new light to the world, and it shows me just how ignorant and fearful all of the bystanders actually were. It both amazes me and frightens me that people could be so afraid of taking a stand or exposing the heinous and despicable actions that the Nazis were committing. I just can’t believe it. I mean, if I was someone who knew about the death camp then I would at least have done SOMETHING in order to try and save some lives. Now, I do understand that some of them were scared and so of course they wouldn’t go to the camp themselves and fight, but I do think that the people could have at least tried to let somebody know about the camp so that the Jews could get some kind of help. The fact that the bystanders who saw this camp, smelled the burning flesh and decided to ignore all of these signs and continue to go about their lives as though they saw nothing truly terrifies me.
ReplyDeleteHere is just another example to add on to the proof that locals had the knowledge that all of this was going on. They all had at least somewhat of an understanding of all the death and torture that was going on. If the small pile of shoes you passed in the museum was significant enough for you to recall the smell then I can't even begin to imagine what one of these camps would smell like. Nor would I ever like to know. Its so terrible that so many people let all of this happen and continue to repeatedly occur even though it was groups of death continuously occurring. It is scary to read, "they didn't have time to destroy these camps". they knew they were doing wrong. they knew everything was wrong yet carried on like blind cattle. its crazy how easily someone can be brainwashed.
ReplyDeleteThis infuriated me. The crematorium and the camp itself were both easily accessible and clearly visible to the public, which means that citizens CHOSE to turn a blind eye and ignore what was occurring right under their nose! But oh, sure, “at least it's not happening to ME!” or, “It's none of MY business!” or, “Not MY problem!!” The Nazis were deceptive and twisted. Not only did they fool the public and even themselves, but they managed to intentionally deceive the Jews as well by tricking them into thinking that everything was going to be fine. Yet, in this case, they didn't even TRY to fool the public; the townsfolk just decided to be bystanders (and therefore accomplices) to mass murder. Even after 70 years, the stench of death lingers in that god-awful place, and it's almost as much the bystanders’ faults as it is the Nazis who directly carried out these orders.
ReplyDeleteMore horror that took place at in a Nazi Death Camp, going beyond that of human comprehension. Loved reading the Mountain of Jewish Shoes Left Behind Poem, by Moshe Shulstein, the great Yiddish poet. I found his poem especially insightful when he refers to the shoes of grandchildren and grandparents, from Paris to Prague, that because they were made of leather, not flesh and blood, each one was able to escape hellfire. Leaving still, the uncertain destiny of the Nazi soul. I was taken back a step or two to hear that the US Holocaust Memorial Museum in DC, preserved the horror of the Nazis with “the smell of shoes in a small area”, yet what better keeping for a museum to stir Holocaust memories through the sense of smell.
ReplyDelete-Russ
How were people driving by this camp and not saying anything?!?!? It makes absolutely no sense. I could never walk or drive by a place knowing that so many of them were dying!!! Despite the incredibly horrible circumstances that the camp was put up, the fact that it was left up and EVERYONE from the rest of the world got to see what was really happening was a good outcome. Also, once again, deception and lies coming from the Nazis is incredibly barbaric. Not only did they deceive the Jews by placing the camp where outsiders could see them, which gave them false hope that it was just a labor camp, but the Nazis killed them in the “showers!” That is so incredibly sad. They had to get naked and strip themselves of any remaining self respect that they had. They were even given false hope once inside the “showers!” Could they get any more deceptive??????
ReplyDeleteIt’s sickening to hear that people drove by this camp and didn’t speak up. Yes, they were probably scared or didn’t wanna do anything because it didn’t affect them but that still makes them bystanders. They continued to trick the Jews which is really sad. Killing in gas chambers is one thing but in the showers is another. It was so unexpected and cruel of them. They should have more common sense than this and know that what they are doing is wrong and shouldn’t have been done in the first place.
ReplyDeleteThe pictures from this post were sickening. The gas chamber was so different than I had imagined it looking. The stains on the walls from the Zyklon B were so upsetting because they showed the terrible things that they did in the gas chambers. The shower heads represent how duplicitous the Nazis were when trying to make the Jews feel safe. The mountain of ash was so upsetting because I can’t even imagine the number of bodies that were burned to create such a large mountain. I remember seeing all the shoes in the Holocaust museum and it was always so sad the see the small shoes that once belonged to children. The poem perfectly describes the feelings you get when you look at all the shoes because you remember that they used to belong to human being whose live was interrupted and taken from them.
ReplyDeleteJane Jeffries
I don't understand how people claimed they didn't know about it? It was in plain sight. It is crazy to think that people denied knowing about it. The pictures of the gas chambers made me feel super uneasy. The fact that I was looking at a place where thousands of people would die of a painful death made me sick. I can't believe you even went in there. The fact that they used that much Zyklon B in the gas chamber that it caused a build up on the wall is crazy and disturbing. What is ironic about that is that it made the color blue on the wall and the color blue is what is on the Israeli flag. I remember seeing the shoes exhibit when we went to DC for our 8th grade field trip. Looking at all the shoes that people once walked in was super eerie. I felt as if all those people were watching us from inside their shoes. The pictures of the ash mound are disgusting. To know that all those people were burned up and just tossed on the ground like nothing is sickening. When you said that you saw bone fragments in the mound made me want to throw up. I hate what the Nazi's did. That's all I can say.
ReplyDeleteBenjamin
Majdanek had a crazy life as a camp. It is terrible for the people who lived there and even worse for the people sent there. I wonder why the Nazis never got a chance to destroy the gas chambers. I wonder what it was like to be inside a gas chamber. I wonder if it would feel dangerous and claustrophobic or if it would be strangely comforting because it can’t harm anybody anymore. Again, like all other death camps, these people did not know. I wonder what sick person came up with this horrible idea and what sick group of people decided to use it. I wonder why they had to get naked. It seems like the Nazis had a committee of people whose one job was to humiliate Jewish people as much as possible.
ReplyDeleteNate Reiney
It made it a lot more real to be able to look pictures of the camp. I think having the gas chambers and crematoria still visible helps remind people to not forget what happened. I can’t believe how many camps, especially this death camp, were so close to locals. This reinforces the problem with bystanders, and I honestly think that the residents of these towns who ignored what was happening are just as bad as the perpetrators, who were harming the victims. I have heard about the deception used several times but to see it was surreal. I was aware of the signs that were used such as “Work makes you free”, but the pictures of the “Bath and disinfection” sign makes it so real. I felt horror when reading the descriptions about the process of death and deception. Again, hearing exactly what happened from the prisoners made it seem even more terrifying. I can’t imagine walking into the unknown like many of them did. I was really disturbed by the fact that the Nazi soldiers used headstones from Jewish cemeteries to make pavements. They had absolutely no respect to Jewish people, and I think that is just the lowest of the low.
ReplyDeleteElla Page
Every time I read another one of your blogs, it strikes me how the Nazis get more and more disgusting. I still have no idea why they attempted to cover up what they were doing. This truly proves that the people working in concentration camps were not just following orders because they clearly thought that what they would have been leaving behind for the Russians and Americans to find was too horrible to get blamed for. Another thing that you wrote about in this blog was how the stones that helped to roll out perfect, flat cement were made of of the headstones of Jewish people. This is extremely offensive for any culture, but since you taught us that the body of a buried Jew is not supposed to be disturbed after 24 hours, this definitely broke that religious law.
ReplyDeleteI am still confused how people have come to believe that the people surrounding concentration and death camps did not know about them. Before we started this unit, I did not know that the people knew. I thought they had no idea, but there is no way they didn’t know about these camps. It is crazy that people could have seen the camp driving by in their car. Why didn’t these people do anything to stop the camps? Why did they choose to remain bystanders? It is crazy that Great Britain and the United States dismissed the death camp as Soviet propaganda. Why did they not step in and help? I cannot believe that they labeled the barrack as bath and disinfection. The Nazis were extremely deceitful in all of the camps. After reading some of these blogs, I have realized how scared the Nazis were of rebellion. They used trickery in order to keep the people in order. They didn’t want to face rebellion. They knew they were wrong, and they didn’t want to tell the victims the truth in order to prevent this rebellion. It is really interesting that the Polish prisoners made the symbolic statue. I had never heard of that before. Thank you for including the poem and the pictures throughout the blog. This is the last blog in the series for me. Thank you for writing these blogs for us to read. I learned a lot of interesting information from them, and I appreciate the time you took to write them. Thank you.
ReplyDelete-Elyse Duley
“We didn’t know,” I can’t stand to think that so many people tried to claim innocence during these actions when the proof was right there and a mere driving or walking distance away. It’s horrendous! The brutality of this camp and the changes it underwent to become something so evil is also horrendous. I can’t fathom how people actively chose to do this and enjoy the shame it causes. It was especially chilling reading the first hand accounts of the camp survivors and they were so vividly described I almost felt like I was there, it was sickening. -Madison
ReplyDeleteAfter reading about Majdanek, it made me wish that I had assigned more blame to the villagers and surrounding population on the “Who to Blame” chart because this camp was in plain site. It is impossible to not see the buildings and even if you didn’t get that close, there had to be a ton of noise and smoke coming from the area. It is disgraceful that no one there decided to do anything. The amount of deception there is unreal too. The poor victims were thinking that they were there to work, but no, there unsuspecting death was coming in just hours. It’s truly sickening to think about millions of innocent people getting painful, unsuspecting deaths just because of their beliefs. The pictures were hard to look at, especially the one that showed the Zyklon B stained on the wall. The places were so well preserved that it makes it that much scarier to think about what went on in that exact spot eighty years ago.
ReplyDeleteImagine being tired from a long, grueling journey on a train to a foreign place. Personally, I would be comforted by the idea of a shower which is why I believe that form of manipulation was the cruelest. It pains me to put myself someone’s shoes that endured that painful death. I do not think I could be as brave us you and actually enter the gas chamber where it happened. It shocks me that after all of this time, people still want to deny that these terrible events did not occur. Passing true historically accurate films off as Russian propaganda is ridiculous!!! I hope that the education of many children in the future will help with this problem. One picture that really scarred me was of the peep whole that the Nazi’s looked through to make sure the Jews were all dead. How terrible of a sight. Also, it is so eerie that you saw ravens and crows everywhere. I would be scared out of my mind if I saw one of those there! I remember going to the Holocaust museum and also being nauseated by the shoes there. The poem gave me a new perspective of all that those shoes had endured.
ReplyDelete-Sophie Slayden
It struck me as odd that the Nazis allowed the POWs to build a statue. I understand that they needed them to work, but it just doesn't seem like them to make their prisoners happy. Whenever they want to encourage prisoners to work they usually just threatened them with death. I liked how they used the opportunity to try and communicate with the new prisoners through symbols. Even the minor victories seem great in the middle of such a tragic time.
ReplyDelete-Brain Ramsey
Majdanek was a camp used for many different things, all of which were horrible. The camp became a death camp when the Nazis created the final solution because they needed more places to send the Jews to be killed. It sickens me that the Nazis physically did not have enough places to KILL PEOPLE that they kept having to build new gas chambers. Again, the duplicity of the Nazis is shown when the Jews were tricked into thinking that they would work at the camps when they were actually just going to be killed as soon as they arrived. The fact that the camp was left intact when it was captured is good because it shows all of the awful things that the Nazis were doing, and they weren't able to destroy the evidence of mass killings. It is also good because we can see the death Chambers and learn from the atrocities of the Nazis that something like this should never happen again.
ReplyDelete-Mac Patterson
I don’t think I could ever have stepped foot into the gas chamber. I think it is very important to remember and raise awareness of what occurred, but I really don’t think I would have been able to stand in there. The looming presence of what could’ve been if those people were not killed would be too heavy for me. Even just the blue stains on the walls and imagining all of the gassings that had to take place for that to occur would make me nauseous. I remember seeing the piles of shoes in the Holocaust museum and being overwhelmed by those, but at Majdanek, it’s completely different because you know those shoes came to that camp and never were used again. The shoes at the musuem are set up there as an exhibit, but they weren’t specifically abandoned at that location. I found that poem about the shoes really moving, and I found that it lined up with a lot of the feelings I felt towards the shoes being there for the reason they are. I also can’t believe how much ash was saved. That whole dome would make me really upset to look at also like being in the chamber would.
ReplyDeleteMoriah Campbell
After hearing so much about the Nazis concealing the death chambers, it brought the question of why the Jews thought they were going to a better place. There was a lot of discriminative towards them and they believed they were heading to a brighter place. But I can't imagine what it was like to step inside a gas chamber, a place where countless people died. It must have been really sickening. Looking through some of the pictures made me surprised. When I saw that mountain of ashes I was shocked. It made me sorrowful that all those people had to die. It's also disturbing me to know that 30,000 innocent people got buried in that pit.
ReplyDelete-Carson Bahr
The things were visible and people knew what was happening and saw the burning of bodies yet they did nothing. I really just don't get it still. I need to know why somebody did this, and there seems to be no reason. Killing people will gas and making them suffer. Then proceeding to burn them after they're dead. It seems unimaginable yet so real at the same time. I always get feelings of things or hear sounds around me when I go to places such as cemeteries or just places that are quiet in general. I just don't know how I would feel going through the concentration camp or what I would hear or think of. The shoes did really speak to me at the US Holocaust museum and I think the poem I feel like it displays what the actual symbolism is to shoes. Everyone wears them everywhere which is why they become attached to people or vice versa. To think that there were people the same age as me wearing those across a journey to their death makes me try to say something that I don't know how to say. The death camps are just hard to read about purely because this is where all the pain and abuse for most ended. In a shack being told you were going to get to shower.
ReplyDeleteRyan Szeker
The first piece of information that shocked me was how the locals did not do anything about the concentration camp despite being able to see inside of it. I do not understand how they would have been able to go on with their life knowing people were being murdered in gas chambers just down the road. I am also repulsed by them of saying the camp was “Bath and Disinfection Centers,” and by the Nazis having them get naked in front of everyone. The Nazis cruelty never ceases to disconcert me. What urged them to do something like this is one thing that I will never understand. I have to say, I am relieved that they were not able to burn this death camp down. This way, people are actually able to further see what disgusting people the Nazis were. It was also really saddening to see the metal pipes that released the Carbon Monoxide that killed so many victims. I cannot will myself to imagine all of those people killed by it.
ReplyDeleteHalsey Patrick
Again, the sheer enormity leaves me dumbfounded. 30,000 lives lost in one day? Mountains of ashes and shoes? I'm disgusted by the Nazis' deception and heartless perception of innocent people. I'm only glad that the structures were preserved to show how unbelievably discriminatory these monsters were. It is a site to learn from and be shocked by. I've always had an appreciation for poetry, so the one about the shoes really struck a chord with me. It put words to what I was thinking when my jaw was to the floor with grief. The real photos you've provided have given a whole new insight as well. I'm so used to staring at a textbook and reading numbers and dates; I couldn't imagine being there in the flesh. These death camps are the most heart-wrenching part of all.
ReplyDelete-Annie Vedder
I will never understand why the Nazis would kill the prisoners with gas, and then proceed to burn the bodies. I will also never understand why people could see inside the death camp, and yet, they did nothing about it. Reading this blog made me wish I had assigned more blame to the Bystanders during class assignments. I always reasoned that people were unaware of these camps, but no, the camp was situated where people could literally even see inside of it. Furthermore, while reading, I found it surprising that the polish prisoners were given permission from the Nazis to build a statue. This seemed like a kind gesture because the prisoners were happy about building the statue, but I just don’t understand why the Nazis wanted Jews to “work” by building the statue. This statue was ironic as it was a symbol for freedom that stood in the middle of a Nazi camp. I am glad that they didn’t burn this death camp down because people are able to learn more about the Nazis’ evil actions through this camp. Seeing the pipes that released the carbon monoxide was devastating.
ReplyDelete-Sara Trochanowski
This camp was also an equally disturbing place. The Nazis just had to decieve the Jews on final time before they died. I assume this is becauase the more deceptive they were about their deaths, the less resistance the Jewish people had. It's all really a sick joke when you think about it because the details of deception were even down to naming the barracks "Bath and Disinfection" center. However, I also liked the fact that you included the location of the camp relative to the rest of the town. How can the people even claim that they didn't know?? The last thing I want to say about this blog is that I was very disturbed that 30,000 people died on the last day of the killings. That it like 15 9/11s combined. It's really hard to fathom that amount of death because it is just so much! All I can do is imagine what it would be like to be completely stuck in a death camp. You would know that you were going to die so how would you react?
ReplyDeleteI have to say, I am relieved that they were not able to burn this death camp down. This way, people are actually able to further see what disgusting people the Nazis were. It was also really saddening to see the metal pipes that released the Carbon Monoxide that killed so many victims. I cannot will myself to imagine all of those people killed by it. Its unnerving to know that the camp was in plain sight and turned away and acted as if they saw nothing. It is unbelievable that you could just ignore what was happening. To call polish and Jewish people “prisoners” of war is so wrong in so many ways because they were not soldiers. . I cant imagine going for a run and passing billowing plums of smoke and a fleshy smell in the air. Im glad they didn't have time to dismantle the place and that all the evidence is right there.
ReplyDeleteI'm tempted to say there are no words and submit this reaction. Honestly, there isn't much to be said in the face of such sadistic actions (I struggled to find the appropriate adjective for a few minutes). To a point, there is no explanation, there is no rationalization, and there is no excuse. I find it vicious how the Nazis went out of their way to humiliate and subdue the Jews. The Jews could have been gassed clothed, but the Nazis robbed them of their dignity. The roads could have been made out of cement, but the Nazis chose to make roads out of Jewish headstones. They must have found that hilarious. Even in death, the Nazis still walked on the Jews. In the end, the Nazis did not win. Majdanek stands witness to the crimes. The Nazis were unable to hide their crimes and thus the world may pass judgement. One thought though, if the Nazis were so certain that they were upholding good and were righteous in their cause, why were they so eager to destroy evidence of the camps? If they truly thought they were righteous, they would have left it up as a tribute to their actions. Perhaps deep down, even the most horrendous Nazis knew how their actions were perceived?
ReplyDelete-Ely A
I can't even begin to think what I'd do if I saw this death camp driving by. What are you supposed to do? The government can't help you and the police might throw you in a death camp if you proposed a counter opinion against Nazism. Because of all the false signs for "shower room" and "disinfectant room" I wonder if there would be more run away Jews if the Nazis were honest about their fate. Keeping the Jews content had to have been the main reason why the Nazis were able to kill so many. After looking at the death chambers with blue evidence only made the Holocaust more real. I don't know how people believed the Holocaust never happened with this much evidence to support it. Seeing the mountain of ashes put into prospective the amount of lives stolen. The mountain of ashes didn't even represent all the bodies killed. --Marin Boulware
ReplyDeleteThat mountain of ash is a good memorial but awful reminder of what had been done. This camp had the most deaths in one day with 30,000. It's such a big number it's hard to think about, and every single one of those 30,000 was a single individual with a life and family. After analyzing the poem “Shoes” in class, being able to match the words with that picture of the shoes was scary. What we have been reading about was real. The torture and inhumanity was all real. The fact that the German citizens could so easily see what was going on right in front of them makes it even worse. It is terrible the citizens stood by and allowed this camp to remain functioning without question. -Macey Smith
ReplyDeleteSeeing the photos of the ashes and shoes broke my heart. None of the "victims" deserved any of this. I can't imagine how it would be to drive through the front entrance of the camp and see various gas chambers right on the way in. The Nazis weren't ashamed to show everyone that they were killing thousand of innocent people a day. I also can't imagine how it must have been to step foot in the actual gas chamber where thousands were killed. Also, the mountain of shoes and pile of ashes were heartbreaking. The idea that the Nazis valued the shoes over the victims' lives is awful.
ReplyDeleteOne other aspect that is shocking to me is the number of people who still believe that the Holocaust never happened. This death camp proves it all; there is evidence of the torturous gas chambers and ashes.
- Caroline Mecia
DeleteMajdanek had a drastic change through its history, it started as a ghetto and transitioned to a death camp eventually. The fact that the camp wasn't even attempted to be hidden and in fact open from all sides with nothing blocking what's going on is disgusting. The Nazis didn't have time to destroy this evidence here, and this camp was featured on the front of The New York Times. The disgusting Nazis showed no mercy towards the Jews and even enjoyed humiliating them before their death, and lied to them. They were forced to undress in front of one another in the "shower to disinfect" the Jews. Little did the Jews know, that's the last they'd see each other, because those "showers" were actually gas chambers that were filled with zyklon B. That poem sure looks familiar, and seeing all of those shoes of children is sickening. -Jayden Childress
ReplyDeleteIt is entries like these that leave me astonished about how people in today's society still believe that the Holocaust never happened. I mean, if this isn't sufficient enough evidence i don't know what it. Also, I personally think that all of the townspeople knew about the camp, but I just don;t know why they wouldn't do anything. Like you said, the Nazis were not trying to hid anything. But the must have done something or said something to the townspeople that scared them so much to where they wouldn't mention the camp and even deny that it existed. It shocked me that the chambers still wrecked 70 years after. That shows me just how many times the Nazis took the jews though the gas chambers and fires for it to still wreck of scent nearly a century later.
ReplyDelete-CarterHensley
Reading the poem "Shoes" before reading this truly emphasizes the scale of this disaster. As I was reading the poem, I thought the "mountain of Shoes" would only be a few hundred shoes, but looking at the pictures of the hallway with to many shoes to count is truly sickening. This camp truly puts Holocaust deniers, or those who scale it down into their place. Someone cannot look at these pictures and not believe that this terrible tragedy had taken place. The camp itself is a cruel testament to the Nazis, and those who were forced to suffer under them.
ReplyDeleteFilip Weil
DeleteYet again, examples of Nazi propaganda disgusts me. It never fails to. This camp in particular seems to be a true front of it all. Falsely labeling the barracks to disguise what was truly held within its walls, telling Jews that a better life was ahead of them, making everything appear as though the Germans had the Jews best interest in mind... and it worked! This is the first time I have seen or heard of a peep hole looking into the chambers. I am utterly speechless. This whole camp is still in tact because the Nazis failed to destroy the evidence, and frankly I'm glad. This piece of history shall be remembered forever, and with that, honored.
ReplyDelete-Giuli Iannitti
Your experiences in the gas chambers sound extremely unsettling. I can’t imagine how traumatic it would be to go inside the place where thousands of innocent people were murdered. Yet again, the themes of deception emerge in your blog; however, Majdanek highlighted the Nazis’ increasing arrogance. Even though they used a ton of euphemisms and deception inside the camp, the Nazis just stopped putting effort into concealing the camp from the outside. They knew that the German citizens could tell what was happening, yet they didn’t take any precautions. The Nazis were so confident that no one would try and stop them from murdering people that they stopped disguising their efforts. This blog impacted, shocked, and disgusted me the most.
ReplyDelete- Ava Clark
Once again I am appalled by the Nazi's duplicity. What is the point of lying to human beings right before they die? Why bother? The mountain of ash kind of opens my eyes to the true amount of victims. It's one thing to read "11 million" but its quite different to actually see a mountain of human remains. How can people possibly believe the Holocaust didn't happen when places so well preserved like this exists. The poem "Shoes" paired with actual pictures of the shoes seemed to give it more meaning.
ReplyDelete-Cooper Owens
After reading this, I only wonder why the people living near this camp chose to be bystanders. How could they sit and watch this happening to thousands of people. Your descriptions of the gas chambers truly horrified me. Reading about the hole Nazis looked through to see if the Jews have died made me wonder what they thought about before looking through. Would it not be a horrifying image? Would they actually enjoy seeing this? And how could they repeat this process? This camp disgusted me because of the trickery of "disinfectant" signs and leading the Jews to their death.
ReplyDeleteI hate to see how the Nazis would create these camps and what they did to the people in them. I still can't believe people would still think that the Holocaust was one, a hoax make by the Jews or two, was acceptable. After 70 years, charcoal scent and blue walls still remained. This goes to show the amount of burning and gaming the Nazis did in the time of the camp. Even after reading the other articles it's still hard to believe the amount of deceit they used until the very end. Lied about the process the Jews were being subjected to, the buildings they were kept in, and their own futures wether it be work or death.
ReplyDeleteTaylor Fleeman
The first thing that caught my attention was the fact that the people living in the town surrounding the camp "didn't know" what was happening. They have eyes right? It is also disturbing how the Germans tricked the Jewish people into thinking they had great lives ahead when in fact, they would all die a tragic death. I am glad that the whole camp is still in tact as is serves a reminder to those who were lost and remains as evidence of what the Nazis did. The memory of those involved shall be preserved by the buildings that remain.
ReplyDeleteI was confused on how the locals were unaware of the death camp when it was in plain sight. No trees surrounding the camp, could be reached by car, and it was just open fields. By the Nazis turning the disinfecting places into gas chambers shows how truly deceptive they were. I was in awe when I saw the pictures of the ash next a full body person; it was soooooo much. I also know that since this camp wasn’t destroyed before liberation all the atrocities were visible for the whole world to see. It really opened the eyes to the genocide that had been occurring while other people were just living ordinary lives
ReplyDeleteI truly do not know how to process such horrors. I can not believe that such an awful evil place was able to stand firm in a place in which everyone could see and yet no one did anything. The complete disregard for the Jew's lives is astounding. To degrade them to a level of just complete brokenness and yet still deceive them is unimaginable. I don't know how anyone could kill 30,000 people in ONE day and still believe they are doing the right thing. Then, to on top of that bury them all in the same place, it just shocks me that the Nazi's found ways to torture these people even after death.
ReplyDelete-Ailish Coughlin
I believe the Nazi's knew they were facing their fall, and built this camp to "speed" up their process. It's also hard for me to begin to understand why locals didn't speak up. I wonder if it was out of fear or moral conflicts. Building gas chambers visible to the public is a prime example of how the Nazi's didn't care for what anyone had to say against Hitlers movement, and continued to their own agenda (obviously but wanted to state). I never understood how the Nazi's had the numbers they had to make this possible... The hate you need to have for a group of people to do this would kill a person mentally, much less the thousands of SS officials...
ReplyDelete- David Hanley
I despise the way that the Nazis deceived everyone. With each blogpost, I begin to learn and understand how the Nazis terrorized the Jews. For the Nazis to know they’re sending these people to their deaths and feel the need to humiliate them one more time makes them monsters. I can only imagine how embarrassed and terrified they all felt. I am really glad that the Nazis never had a chance to hide the horrors of this camp; instead, now, the whole world knows the barbarians they truly are. When i saw all the pictures of the gas chambers and the words in the front I couldn’t help but feel death. I could only think of the innocent people who’d been tricked to their deaths.
ReplyDelete~ Savannah S
It must have been so terrifying to enter the encampment and immediately see gas chambers. Going into Majdanek must’ve been like walking straight into your own death, and there was basically nothing they could have done about it. I can’t comprehend why German citizens did nothing about this camp. Obviously, I know why because they were bystanders, but they could’ve done SOMETHING. Everyone could see the camp, and it was extremely easy to get to. The change that took place in Majdanek is also astounding to me. It went from being a normal town, to a ghetto, to a concentration camp. That must’ve been scary for the neighboring towns because they probably knew it could easily happen to them too. It is also enraging that the Nazis took away the dead’s tombstones to make room for pavement. That is so degrading and disrespectful, and it’s just horrible to do to someone.
ReplyDeleteSam Wofford
I was shocked to learn that this camp was built in plain sight. why did no one try to stop what was happening? This camp had no trees surrounding it and the gas chambers were located in the front of the camp. The Jews were once again told that they would get back their belongings after they took a shower. Then they would be sent to work to provide themselves with a better life. This was all a lie. They were sent to the gas chambers. After reading and looking at the pictures I learned that even today the walls are stained with remnants of the gas. This camp was built for the sole purpose. To kill. The Jews that entered the camp never escaped or lived to see the end of the war. I was saddened to learn that the German citizens who lived around the camp were bystanders. They could have done so many things to help the Jews, but instead they just said it was normal. Unlike most of the other camps this camp was captured whole. So everything still stands today. When the New York Times wrote about this camp the story was so unbelievable, that the americans dismissed it a propaganda. This is saddening to me.
ReplyDeleteAnn Slegelmilch
It’s cool how this is one of the death camps that didn't have their gas chambers burned down so tourists are able to go in and see them. This camp is also different because it was not hidden but rather very visibly exposed. I wonder why they didn't try to hide it because many of the other camps had made sure to very carefully. I still do not understand why they tried so hard to trick the Jews into thinking they were going to stay and work there when they were going to kill them in such a short period of time. It seems like more work for the Nazis to do this to the Jews and would take longer to kill them. It's horrible how they were given false hopes about a better life at this camp and that if they worked hard it would pay off. In reality all the Jews had come to the place where their lives would be ended.
ReplyDeleteEmary Gordon
Majdanek was a very interesting camp. It was different from the rest of them because the Nazis had no time to destroy the camp before the escaped. Because of this all of the camp remnants remained in place. I found it horrible that the Nazis labeled the gas chambers as “Bath and Disinfection.” It seems to me that the Jews were constantly being misled over and over again. They went to take a “shower” and they were killed. They went to “relocate” and they were killed. The Nazis put in so much effort, planning, and time to kill innocent, harmless people. It still doesn’t add up correctly. Another thing that I found interesting was the peephole in the door. The Nazis looked through the whole to make sure everyone was dead. This just makes the Nazi’s seem like the most insensitive and indecent people in the world. Well, they were. The picture of the shoes was very heartbreaking because it showed that the Jews were lead to think that they were going to be safe, but then they were killed. And, all of their possessions were forgotten.
ReplyDeleteEmi Jones
Soren Gautam
ReplyDeleteMajdanek is a lot different from the other concentration camps because it was not destroyed as all of the camp still remains to this day. The gas chambers also remain at this camp, and I find it somewhat interesting that tourists can go inside them. However, I find it very disgusting and typical of the Nazis to use a euphamism as a label for the gas chamber with term "Bath and Disinfection." The Jews would also be completely confused when they enter the gas chamber because they would think that they are about to get cleaned up with water before being killed by the gas. The gas chambers also had peepholes on the doors, which I found somewhat creative as the Nazis could make sure the gas was no longer present before entering the gas chamber themselves. However, it still makes them look cruel since they could also check through the peephole to see if all the Jews were dead and then kill those who somehow miraculously survived the gas.
It must have been so difficult to enter those death camps. If I were in your shoes, I'm not sure if I would have had the courage to do that. It astounds me that the death camp was so easily accessible and everyone could see what was happening, yet no one said anything. I agree with the reporter. Although I know that it's not impossible because it is a nonfiction historical event, the existence of a camp with a sole purpose of wiping out a whole religion just sounds impossible. I'm happy that they weren't able to burn any of the evidence because it allowed us to be able to see what they actually looked like. Being able to experience what the buildings were actually like is a lot different than just seeing ruins and destroyed evidence. I don't understand why or how someone would want to look through a peephole so that they could watch the Jews die.
ReplyDeleteSofia Christofaro
It is unbelievable that a place like Majdanek was built and operated in the open and without any attempt to conceal what was happening there. I was surprised they allowed the Polish POWs to erect a statue to make the place nicer. It seems that people who would escalate to exterminating so many would not care about the wishes of the prisoners. I am glad the Germans did not have the opportunity to destroy the camp like they did so many others. It provides evidence that can't be ignored for those who would try to claim that the horrors of the Holocaust are exaggerated. I can't imagine the sight of all of those shoes and knowing that they represent so many victims. I also can't imagine entering the gas chambers used to murder so many. I didn't know that there were 30,000 people killed in a single day. That is an incredible number of people losing their lives at the hands of such monsters. I was disappointed, but not surprised, by the use of the Jewish headstones to make pavements. The Nazis seem to have so many ways to disrespect others. The fact that the Nazis regularly required the prisoners to be naked in front of the masses of victims is yet another cruel way to strip away their dignity. Not only did the Nazis kill the Jews, but they mistreated, deceived, dehumanized, and terrorized them.
ReplyDeleteStanton Bryson
Exposed for everyone to see, yet people who saw Majdanek said they “didn’t know” about it?? How could one avoid the horrors happening right in front of them? It amazed me to read that bystanders could be so oblivious of what was going on. It upset me to read and see that all of the Nazis took measures of deceiving so far that the buildings in the camp were labeled falsely. When everyone arrived, they thought they were going to the showers, not to their death. One interesting thought that crossed my mind while reading the blog was why the Nazis went through the trouble of shaving people’s hair. It then occurred to me that possibly the only reason was to fully deceive the arriving Jews, but it surprises me that they would put that much effort into a pointless task. Also, despite how painful it must have been to plod throughout the camp, it is important that people learn about and see what the conditions truly were. The fact that Majdanek was not destroyed aids the disturbing past not to be forgotten.
ReplyDelete-Gillian Morano
I can not imagine walking into a concentration camp and the first thing I see be a gas chamber. It must have been heart wrenching to see the gas chambers first. I am actually glad that the Nazis were unable to destroy the gas chambers because they prove all that the Nazis are guilty for. I think that the visible placement of the camp was intentional by the Nazis to scare the citizens. Again with the trickery and deception, the Jews had no idea they were going to die. It is a good thing that Majdanek was captured whole. This allows us to understand more of how death camps were set up and gives us proof of the Holocaust happening. The statue that the prisoners made was very creative and beautiful. I can not believe the Nazis would go as far as telling the prisoners to remember where their items were before they walked into a gas chamber. Peeping through a little hole to see if all their victims were dead is something I could never in a million years imagine doing. There was so much ash in that picture. I couldn’t believe it.
ReplyDelete- Ashley Szymonski
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteJordan Browning
ReplyDeleteIt is disheartening to learn that citizens knew about the camp, yet nothing was done to stop all the crimes. I assume that some agreed with the Nazis and others were just too scared to do anything. I cannot say what I would have done if I were in that situation, but I hope that I would have said or done something. I'm surprised none of the ghetto was torn down, so it's all there. The blue walls on the chambers are sickening because they prove how much the gas was used. Like the other camps, they tricked Jews to their own deaths. That ash pile was gigantic! I'm surprised that after 70+ years, it was still there. That must me so scary to stand there knowing it's the remnants of previous Jews and victims of the holocaust.
It pains me to see how deceptive the Nazis were to the Jews. They gave them a false hope of survival when really, their ultimate fate was already decided. Also, the fact that they labeled the barracks as showers and disinfection centers is ludicrous! Something that absolutely disgusted me is how much the Nazis disrespected the Jews and their religious beliefs. The fact that they made them get naked in front of everyone is cruel and insane. Judaism highly values modesty, so I can't imaging how scared and embarrassed the Jews were when they did this. Those pictures are horrific. The ash pile is bigger than I would have ever imagined. The fact that the lives of so many amazing people lay in a huge ash pile is sickening.
ReplyDeleteAva Harrell
It was very disturbing and saddening to learn that 30,000 innocent lives were taken in a few hours, but it was reassuring to know that the camp had been preserved and that the nazis hadn’t had time to destroy the evidence of these terrible killings, unlike many other camps. Since the camp is preserved, the mass murders can still be physically proven in order to provide evidence against deniers and so that this tragedy isn’t forgotten. The enormous mountain of ash was able to help me visualize just how many innocent people had their lives taken and also serves as a reminder of the horrific events that took place in the camp.
ReplyDeleteLeo O’Neill
Deception strikes again. The arrogance of the Nazis strikes again. They think that they can just kill people for no good reason. The normal soldiers don't even stand up for them. They just let it happen. "Yup, right this way everyone. You're all getting a... uhhh... really good bath!" How? How did the "normal" people go along with it. Did they think it was okay? Why did they not question it? What is wrong with them?!
ReplyDeleteEthan Fronapfel
DeleteIt is unbelievable that people could just ignore what was happening considering it was happening right in front of them. To call polish and Jewish people “prisoners” of war is so wrong in so many ways because the Nazis had no ligament reason to imprison these groups. The fact that the camp burned 30,000 people in one day is insane to me. That is close to killing someone every second. It sickens me to think of how the Nazis deceived the Jews. I do not know how any sane people could be able to sit down and come to decisions on the best way to burn people and get rid of their bodies. The way the Nazis shamed and humiliated the Jews for no reason shows just how barbaric the Nazis were. I can’t imagine what it was like for the Jews to be humiliated in front of their peers. I wonder how badly the survivors were scarred mentally. I can not imagine being able to have hope in a place filled with so much hate.
ReplyDelete-Lila Barenberg
It is honestly pretty cool that you got to see the gas chambers and crematoria. The Holocaust used so many euphanisms so maybe that is why people did not understand what was going on throughout these camps. It is crazy though how in such an open camp no one notices anything suspicious going on, or at least they claim not to. The tricks the Nazis played on the Jews were breathtaking. How were they able to convince a whole population of people nothing bad was happening even when everything going on around them was gruesome. How were they able to gain Jews trust to the point where they could find out where their belongings were? The gas chamber to this day still looks disgusting. The fact that the walls were permanently stained blue from all the Zyklon B is sickening. The Nazis making Jews roll heavy barrels of pavement from Jewish headstones is straight up cruel. The fact that they just took the time to make the headstones into pavement shows the cruelty and unneeded acts of the Nazis. I really like the idea behind the statue built by the Polish prisoners. Killing 30,000 people in one day is like killing a few cities in one day. That is crazy. The outside of the dome memorial is designed really pretty, but it is sad to see all the ashes of the dead Jews. You can really see the age of the shoes in the last picture. It is breathtaking to see the amount of shoes that were left behind from all the innocent Jews.
ReplyDelete- Emma Groves
While reading this blog post I was baffled by the idea that the locals had no idea of the camp. Since it wasn’t blocked on the sides by trees it was completely visible; therefore, locals should not have been able to use the excuse that they didn’t know it existed. I was also very saddened by the fact that the gas chambers were labeled with pleasant things such as “bath.” The Jews thought they were simply going o get clean and prepare for their stay at the camp but little did they know they were going to be murdered. The fact that a death camp even existed, let alone multiple, is shocking. How could something so evil exist in this world? That is one question I will continue to ask myself far after this unit is over. I truly don’t know how a group of people could devote their lives to creating a place dedicated to ending lives.
ReplyDelete-Lexi Amedio
I find it surprising that one of the camps is found with evidence. The gas chambers were still there. The Nazis used a variety of different euphemisms and it is cool that you got the chance to see how it actually happens. The Nazis actions can be proven with evidence. This must have been very terrifying to actually see where the Nazis killed the Jews and how the ghetto worked. I am terrified of how the Jews died in the “baths.” They were sprinkled with cold water then boiling water, and if they ran off, they would be hit with whips. All of the Nazis’ actions disgust me! I do not understand how the Nazis can take away all of a person’s belongings. Also, I cannot believe that there were so many ashes preserved. These ashes showed a ton of bodies and it is frightening how you can even see body fragments.
ReplyDelete- Emma Grace Parker
Wow, reading this blog felt a lot more as you said, real. The camp was not destroyed, and everything was still there for all to see. The camp was in complete plain sight! How could nobody do nothing about it! People knew it was there and by being bystanders and ignoring it, so many people were killed. The Jewish people entering the camps all thought that they might be ok, and they had a false sense of hope. They did not even know they were going to die, they simply thought they were showering. I don’t think that will EVER seem less horrible to me than it does now.
ReplyDelete- Lillian Smith
The disrespect is unreal. I can't believe they used Jewish headstones for pavement, and how they made them become naked to humiliate them. I can't imagine driving around my own town and seeing a camp where thousands are being murdered. I would have to say something! I don't understand how the citizens just stood around; they were cowards. I also remember reading in another blog how the Nazis wanted the deaths to be as humane as possible. I think the Nazis did many things to torture the Jews, not make their deaths humane. Why would they shave their heads and tell them to remember where their belongings were? What came out of this deception? It was just cruel and disrespectful.
ReplyDelete-Evan Pratt
The devil is in the details. The switch from wood to brick. The cycle of scalding and freezing water. The enforced nudity and the shame that came with it. Headstone concrete. Visibility. The acid “bath.” I looked up what carbolic acid can do to a person, and I’m surprised that the person who reported it survived. The acid itself won't kill, but it would make a man useless as a laborer, and because of this, useless for the nazis to keep alive. Today we learned that cruelty escalated as a result of social pressures and the desire to build a reputaion. I don't understand how this reputation could be desired.
ReplyDelete-sophie Thrasher
Makayla Gathers
ReplyDeleteSince the Majdanek ghetto was out in the open, this is further proof that every citizen should’ve been held accountable for the many deaths of the Jews. The Nazis were very manipulative and cunning. I’m glad that Majdanek was captured whole. Several people from outside of Poland tried to ignore the Holocaust, or they simply didn’t want to believe the Holocaust. After the camp was captured, the people were able to see what the Nazis did. They were able to see everything without it being sugarcoded. It’s sad that even after they were able to see the truth, they still weren’t able to believe the actions of the Nazis. I’m glad there was proof of the Holocaust left, but it was also very sad to look at. The ash and bone fragments are very hard to look at, but we have to remember that it was even harder for these people. This is the only way their story is able to be told, and we all have a job to remember.
It is good that they didn't have time to destroy the death camp because it can help show the people what the Nazis actually did and how cruel they were. It is shocking that everyone could see the death camp gas chambers, and crematories but they claim they never knew. It is horrible that the Germans tricked the Jews that they had a chance to live by changing the names of everything while the Nazis were just leading the Jews to their death. It is great that it was posted on New York Times because it helped spread the message of what they did.
ReplyDelete- Sebastian Zarta
Although a few "untouchables" may have helped in different structures, the part regardless I don't exactly get is the means by which effectively these individuals could declare that they "had no clue" what was happening. Given that the camp is on display, simple to get to via vehicle, and not secured with trees, it is difficult for me to accept that such a large number of individuals were "visually impaired" about this whole procedure. Is it safe to say that they were too frightened to even think about stepping up? Were the "spectator" activities out of unadulterated dread? Would individuals turn a "visually impaired eye" if this happened again today? The individual portions about the "shower and sanitizing" forms were extremely exceptional in methods for portrayal. I was stunned at how rapidly these Nazis deceived the Jews and how rapidly the procedure was finished. These Jews were dehumanized inside and out. They were stripped bare of dress and hair, which made them considerably progressively defenseless and unfit to stand up to. I couldn't envision how it could have felt to have been dealt with so ineffectively that soon to my demise. In conclusion, the way that you could even now smell the consuming charcoal following 70 YEARS stuns me. In the event that the smell still exists today, I can't envision what number of lives were taken.
ReplyDelete-Sunil Mehta
I can’t even imagine what it was like when the camp was first liberated. Without being able to burn the evidence beforehand, all the Nazis actions were visible to everyone. The people who liberated the camp must have been nauseated. I also can’t imagine the smell back then. If there was still a distinct smell after 70 years, it must have been horrific at the time. I also find it horrible that they would tell the Jews to remember where they put their stuff even though they knew it didn’t matter. I would also be very ashamed if I was told to undress in front of thousands of people. If the camp was visible to the German citizens, I find it horrendous that nobody tried to help the Jews even though they could see what they were going through. I was also very disgusted by the small peep hole the Germans used to see if everyone was dead. They put thousands of people into a room to kill them, and they make a little peep hole just to double check. Some people might not see it as offensive as I do, but I just hate that they made that. I am glad that there was a statue put for the prisoners to be inspired by though. It was good that the Germans didn’t realize what it truly meant. I just find all of it very disturbing. From the smell of the camp to the mountain of ash and shoes. Everything that happened is just so tragic.
ReplyDelete-Jordan Taylor